5 Outlaws Threatened to Burn an Old Rancher Alive — Then He Said, “They Should've Brought More”

Chapter 24

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The title examinations brought unpleasant surprises. Two deeds appeared to have been signed on days when their original owners were absent from the county. Another included a payment acknowledgment the seller said had been added after he put down his name. Pritchard's attorney disputed the accusations and argued that memory could not be trusted months after a sale. Brooks gathered postal records, witnessed receipts, and testimony from the person who had prepared the documents. Each new discovery made the case more complicated. It also made a simple resolution through force less likely, because the facts were beginning to reach judges who could order proper remedies.

Samuel attended one hearing at the county seat. He wore a plain dark coat rather than the green poncho and carried a walking stick. The judge asked whether he understood that a gunfight on his property would not automatically excuse every shot fired. Samuel answered that he understood. He described the threat, the first shot at the porch, and his efforts to keep his hired hands from entering the fight. He admitted he could no longer remember the exact order of every movement. The judge appeared to respect the uncertainty more than a perfect account might have deserved.

Miriam testified afterward. The attorney for Pritchard asked why a woman her age had kept a pistol in the house if she intended to live peacefully. "Because living peacefully isn't the same as living carelessly," she answered. He asked whether she and her husband were famous gunfighters from the south. Miriam looked at him steadily. "You may call us whatever people used to call us. It won't change what happened at our house." The judge instructed the lawyer to confine his questions to relevant events. Miriam stepped down with her dignity intact and a sharp pain in her bandaged wrist she would not mention until they reached home.

The court found enough evidence to proceed on the allegations involving coercion, arson, and conspiracy. The immediate question of Samuel and Miriam's use of force was examined separately, with the physical evidence and eyewitness accounts supporting their claim that they had defended themselves and others against armed attack. Pritchard did not become harmless because a judge set a hearing date. He still controlled money, knew influential men, and could make the legal proceedings expensive. But he could no longer pretend there were no witnesses or records contradicting his story.

The Wades paid their own attorney out of savings accumulated over decades. When word reached the valley, neighbors began bringing small contributions: eggs, sacks of grain, hay, a repaired harness, and once a paper envelope containing three dollars from a woman who refused to give her name. Samuel objected that they were not beggars. Miriam told him that accepting help was not begging any more than giving help was purchasing gratitude. He considered the distinction for a day before admitting she was right. It was not easy for a man who had spent half a lifetime being the one others relied upon.

News in the same category

5 Outlaws Threatened to Burn an Old Rancher Alive — Then He Said, “They Should've Brought More”

30 Part