5 Outlaws Threatened to Burn an Old Rancher Alive — Then He Said, “They Should've Brought More”

Chapter 21

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

He began with the physical facts. His deputy recorded the positions of the fallen riders, collected weapons, photographed the damage to the porch and barn, and asked a physician to examine the injuries. Amos and Daniel described where they had been standing and what they had seen. Ada confirmed that Calder had demanded a signature and threatened the house immediately before the first shots. Each witness was interviewed separately to avoid their memories becoming a single agreed story. Brooks made a point of telling Samuel and Miriam that what they had done would be examined under the same standards applied to anyone else. They welcomed the assurance, because they had not fought to place themselves above the law.

The sheriff also kept watch over Jonah Ellis. The young man had witnessed crimes and might be charged for his own part in them, but he had information essential to understanding who ordered the intimidation. On the first evening Jonah sat in a jail cell and asked whether his mother would learn what he had done. Brooks answered that he could not prevent the truth from reaching her and would not lie about it if asked. Jonah lowered his head. "Then I ought to tell her myself," he said. The sheriff provided paper and, after reading the letter for threats or efforts to coordinate false testimony, arranged for it to be sent.

Jonah wrote slowly. He told his mother about the land he had lost, the men he followed, and the family whose barn burned while he stood watch on the road. He confessed that he had begun believing excuses because the truth made him ashamed. He did not mention the Wades as heroes. He wrote that an old woman had brought him water when he had no right to expect it, and that the kindness made his own behavior harder to bear. He ended by asking his mother not to forgive him simply because he was her son. He wanted to earn whatever trust could be rebuilt.

Calder survived long enough to be moved to the county infirmary, where a physician removed a bullet and warned that fever might still kill him. He cursed Samuel every time his wound was dressed, then demanded to know whether Pritchard had paid for his care. When Brooks told him Pritchard had denied authorizing violence, Calder went quiet. He had spent years believing loyalty between criminals worked like loyalty between honorable men. Now he understood that Pritchard intended to save himself by describing the riders as independent troublemakers. The realization loosened Calder's tongue more effectively than threats might have done.

He admitted receiving money for pressure on landowners, but insisted that setting the Lindens' barn ablaze had not been his own idea. Brooks asked who had ordered it. Calder answered with enough details to justify bringing Pritchard's bookkeeper in for questioning. The bookkeeper, a thin young man named Edwin Marsh, was

News in the same category

5 Outlaws Threatened to Burn an Old Rancher Alive — Then He Said, “They Should've Brought More”

30 Part