As the deputies prepared to leave, Brooks studied Samuel's poncho. "My father told me a story when I was a boy," he said. "A man in green came to El Paso in fifty-nine and got him safely out of a street that belonged to eight armed thieves." Samuel looked past him toward Miriam, who was replacing the bandages in her tin. "Your father told good stories," he said. Brooks smiled sadly. "He did. He said there was a woman, too." Miriam turned. "There often is," she replied.
The wounded men were taken to town under guard. Pritchard rode in the sheriff's wagon, furious that he had to share a seat with a deputy who refused to listen to his instructions. Samuel watched them go and felt no triumph. There had been a time when he believed that ending a gunfight meant winning it. Age had taught him that every fight continued in the lives of the people left behind. Miriam came to stand beside him, her hand finding his as naturally as breath. They looked at the scorched barn and the yard where the shots had fallen, and for the first time that day Samuel allowed himself to feel how near he had come to losing her.
That evening they sat on the porch while Amos and Daniel quietly repaired the fence. Miriam washed the blood from Samuel's sleeve and laid the green poncho across her lap. "I broke our promise," he said. "No," she answered. "We promised never to fight for pride or profit again. Today we stood for the Lindens, for the boys, for this valley. I didn't want the guns any more than you did, but refusing to protect people would have been a different kind of betrayal." Samuel looked toward the apple trees and wished the distinction offered more comfort than it did.
The investigation moved more slowly than town gossip. Brooks secured statements from the remaining riders, questioned the families who had sold under threat, and asked a judge for authority to examine Pritchard's business records. The land buyer hired a lawyer from Cheyenne, denied ordering violence, and insisted that Calder had acted on his own. Yet the envelope of banknotes in Calder's saddlebag could be traced to a recent withdrawal, and a series of letters showed that Pritchard knew more about the timing of the threats than an innocent buyer reasonably would. The proof assembled gradually, record by record, until even his attorney advised him to reconsider the wisdom of calling every witness a liar.
For the next three days Bell Crossing sounded like a town preparing for war, though the actual gunfight was over. People arrived at the sheriff's office with rumors, accusations, and stories remembered from older disputes. Some said Samuel had fired every shot from the yard without moving his feet. Others insisted Miriam had brought down Calder from the porch while baking bread. One saloon patron claimed the Wades were wanted by three governors, which would have been difficult to explain because two of those governors had not yet been elected. Brooks listened to what might be evidence and sent the rest of the storytellers home.