The railroad officials became concerned as the investigation grew. Their survey team had returned to find several property boundaries in dispute and a land buyer claiming authority he might not possess. The company's representative, Edwin Whitcomb, was a civil engineer who had spent half his career explaining to impatient businessmen that bridges required foundations and schedules required honest estimates. He did not particularly care for Pritchard, but he had originally accepted the man as a useful intermediary. Now he found that the deeds underpinning the proposed route might be challenged and that angry residents no longer trusted anyone who mentioned the railroad.
Whitcomb asked the board for authority to suspend negotiations through Pritchard. His directors feared the delay would raise costs and send the line north instead. He argued that a route acquired through intimidation could produce years of lawsuits, sabotage, and ill will, while a slower negotiation with genuine owners offered a more reliable future. The directors debated until late evening. In the end they approved a limited direct-acquisition program, provided Whitcomb obtained independent title examinations and did not promise more than the railroad could deliver.
When Whitcomb reached the Wade ranch for the first time, he brought no hired guards. He arrived with a folded map, a surveyor named Rachel Cole, and a proposal to examine the southern boundary. Samuel met them at the gate and asked that they leave their horses tied where the ground was firm. Miriam offered coffee before they began. The courtesy surprised Rachel, who had heard wild stories about the old couple and expected an armed reception. She soon discovered that Samuel could discuss drainage, grades, and culvert placement with a practical understanding that many trained engineers had to learn the hard way.
The south pasture held a spring that fed a shallow pool where cattle drank in dry seasons. A track placed carelessly across it could damage the water flow and make the land on both sides less useful. Samuel walked the line slowly, leaning on a stick whenever his knee troubled him. He showed Whitcomb the ground that flooded in April, the place where a wagon had bogged down fifteen years earlier, and the narrow ridge that remained firm through the worst rain. Rachel measured the alternative alignment and discovered that it might require less grading than the company initially estimated.
"That's a useful observation," she told Samuel. He shrugged. "Thirty years of getting wet teaches a man where water goes." Whitcomb laughed, then asked why Samuel did not simply accept Pritchard's earlier offer if he had always intended to discuss the railway. Samuel looked toward the house. "Because he wasn't buying a right of way. He was buying a whole life for two hundred dollars and a threat. There's a difference between a railroad that needs a strip of ground and a man who wants everything he can frighten somebody into giving him." Whitcomb wrote the words down, not because they belonged in a legal contract but because he wanted to remember them.