The night before the preliminary hearing, Sheriff Reed visited the ranch alone. He removed his hat and stood beside the repaired fence, looking at the dark line of exposed soil beyond it. "I owe you an apology," he told Luke. "I came ready to take you into town because a wealthy man had made his account sound tidy." Luke shook his head. "You asked questions. That's your job." Reed glanced toward the house. "I should have asked them before I decided which answer I expected." Nora joined them on the steps. She thanked him for continuing the investigation. Reed answered that thanks could wait until he had done his duty all the way to the end.
In court the following week, Sloane wore a dark suit and sat between two lawyers. Nora dressed in the blue wool gown Ada had helped her mend, and Luke wore a clean coat borrowed from Samuel Finch's uncle. Miriam called witnesses carefully, beginning with the blacksmith, then the apprentice, then Ada. Each described what had been personally seen, not what the town had imagined. Luke explained the fuel can and the bar shoe, making clear that he had not witnessed anyone lighting the fire. Sloane's lawyer tried to discredit him with the Dakota story. Luke acknowledged his past, then described his testimony against Bellamy and the reason he had left. He did not ask the court to find him admirable. He asked it to consider the evidence about this fire.
Nora testified last. She described the first offer, the second offer, the timing of the blaze, and Sloane's arrival with a lower price. The lawyer asked whether her attachment to her dead husband's ranch had clouded her judgment. She answered that losing Benjamin had made her more careful about what she still possessed. The lawyer suggested she had invited Luke to stay because she needed a man to manage matters beyond her experience. Nora looked at the judge. "I invited him to stay because he worked while the rest of us worked," she said. "This place is mine. I make the decisions on it. He knows that better than anybody." Luke looked down at his hands, and Ada squeezed Nora's fingers beneath the bench.
The court found sufficient grounds to continue proceedings, and Sloane was placed under restrictions while the case advanced. It was not the end Nora had imagined on the night of the fire. There were no cheers in the street, no declaration that justice had suddenly become simple. The bank still held her note. The feed had to last until spring. The county road remained muddy, and every night the house was cold before they lit the stove. But Sloane had lost the ability to pretend the fire was an accident that had benefited nobody. His former business partners began separating themselves from his agreements. The sheriff informed Nora that one of them had delivered additional financial records to the prosecutor.