At breakfast Luke told her he expected Sloane to return with the sheriff. "Why?" Nora asked. "Because now he can accuse me of starting the fire, taking the can, or both. He needs your neighbors frightened enough to let him act respectable." Nora stared at her bread. "Sheriff Reed won't arrest you without cause." Luke did not answer. He had seen men invent cause in Dakota and watched respectable officials call it order. She saw his expression and understood why he had traveled alone for six years.
Sheriff Silas Reed arrived before the coffee cooled. Sloane rode beside him in the black buggy, wearing an injured expression. Reed was a broad man in his late fifties with a gray mustache and a tendency to pause before answering, as if checking whether a hard truth could be made softer. He greeted Nora by name and asked after the fire. Then Sloane announced that an itinerant man with a history of working for Bellamy had been seen near the origin of the blaze. He had come, he said, out of civic concern. "A stranger can light a fire and offer to help extinguish it," he added. "The performance earns a widow's trust. Meanwhile her property burns."
Reed looked at Luke. "Is your name Luke Mercer?" "It is." "Did you ride for Cyrus Bellamy in Dakota?" "Six years ago. I left when he burned a farm. I testified about it in Bismarck." Reed's eyes narrowed, not with malice but with the strain of trying to fit an inconvenient story around something a powerful man had already told him. "Why come through this county?" "Because the road runs west." Sloane made a small, contemptuous sound. Nora stepped between the men. "He dug all night to protect my barn," she said. "You can see his work from here." "A clever man might dig the break after setting the fire," Sloane answered. "And a guilty man might arrive next morning with an offer for the land he thought would burn," Nora replied.
The sheriff raised a hand. He had no interest in a quarrel that grew more dangerous with every answer. He asked whether either side possessed evidence. Sloane claimed to have lost a fuel can from his buggy and suggested the drifter might have stolen it. Nora said a can had been found at the origin of the blaze, then taken from her porch by a man who escaped toward town. "Can you prove the theft?" Reed asked. She showed him the drawing of the tracks, but she knew it was less than he wanted. Luke reached into his coat and brought out the horseshoe. "We found this beside the burned line," he said. "It's a left hind bar shoe. Mr. Sloane's mare is wearing a new one."
Reed examined the shoe. He was raised on a stock farm and knew the mark of hand-forged iron. Sloane waved it away. "Half the county uses the same blacksmith." "Not half the county changed one yesterday," Ada Bell said from the road. Nobody had noticed her wagon. She had come