Nora learned something of these dealings through Samuel Finch, whose duties at the bank had involved carrying sealed documents between the manager and local investors. Samuel had once admired Sloane for his polished suits and grand plans. Now he wondered how much of the apparent prosperity around him was financed by people's fear. He did not know whether he could safely speak. At supper he told his mother only that he had seen a thing he wished he had not seen. She put down her fork and said a man who has seen something wrong must decide whether keeping silent is the same as approving it. She did not tell him the decision would be easy. She knew enough about debt to understand the price of conscience.
In the following week Nora received two anonymous letters. The first offered a way out: sell the ranch immediately and a buyer would pay her note plus the cost of a train ticket east. The second threatened to publicize Luke's history unless she stopped accusing Sloane. Neither letter had a return address. The paper was finer than the kind sold at the general store. She preserved both and told Sheriff Reed what had happened. He made copies and asked the postmaster to identify any unusual deliveries without opening private mail unlawfully. Nora had wanted him to arrest somebody. She knew he had to do more than satisfy her frustration if his work was to withstand scrutiny.
Luke was troubled by the letters because they were directed at her reputation rather than her property. He told Nora he would leave if his presence made it harder for her to defend the ranch. She refused to discuss such a choice while they were both angry. That evening she brought out the note Benjamin had written on the day they purchased the mares. It contained a small drawing of the ranch and, beneath it, the words, 'Don't let anybody sell you a smaller life than the one you're building.' She placed the paper between them. "I decide who stays in my house," she told Luke. "Not the man sending letters." He read the words twice before returning the note. The following morning he repaired the broken gate without another mention of leaving.
The first frost arrived while they were repairing the north gate. Luke had become a part of the daily rhythm almost without anyone deciding it. He fed the horses at dawn, helped Nora with the heavy repairs, and took the saddle when supplies required a ride to town. She paid him what little wages she could, and he insisted on recording each sum so no one might say later that he had taken advantage of her. They still argued about fence lines and the direction of the hay stacks. One afternoon she caught him humming while he dug the last drainage trench. The tune reminded her of something from childhood. He said his mother used to hum it every harvest. She asked him to sing it properly someday. He promised to try when there was no one to hear but the horses.