Jonah asked whether Martha had written anything down. Her expression changed. "Every visit," she said. "Every letter. Every time somebody told my husband he owed money we could not account for. I thought if we kept enough pieces, someday a person might understand the whole of it." She looked toward the house, where lamplight had filled the kitchen window. "But I do not know how long I can afford to wait for that person." Jonah did not promise to save her ranch. He asked whether he might see the papers in the morning and whether she knew anyone else who had been driven off land nearby.
That night Martha set an extra plate at the table, though Jonah had first declined. She would not let a man who had buried her cow ride hungry into the cold. He took the chair nearest the door, a habit she noticed without comment. Anna served beans without looking up. Daniel asked Jonah whether he had ever owned a horse that was afraid of gunshots. Jonah answered that every living creature was entitled to be frightened once in a while. Will wanted to know if Daisy would come back in the spring. Martha looked down at her plate, and Jonah let the silence remain until Anna quietly put an arm around her little brother.
When the children were in bed, Martha carried a tin box to the table. Inside were account books, receipts, folded notices, and a photograph of her husband, Thomas, standing beside a wagon at planting time. She told Jonah that Thomas had taken fever after helping a neighbor through a winter storm. By the time the doctor arrived, it was too late. He had left them one hundred and sixty acres, a house with a failing roof, and a mortgage the family had nearly finished paying. The land was not wealthy land, but it had enough grass and water to support cows and children if no one interfered.
Before Thomas died, Silas Rusk had offered to buy the place. He wanted the creek, not the house. Once he had the creek crossing, his cattle could move between his northern and southern pastures without using the public trail. Thomas refused because the offer was not enough to buy a life elsewhere. Silas returned with a second offer, and after that the trouble began. The well water tasted bitter. A supplier stopped extending credit. Fence wire was cut during calving season. When Thomas tried to bring the matter before the county, the sheriff said there was no evidence any of it was connected.
"Maybe some of it wasn't," Martha admitted. "A well can turn bad on its own. A fence can break. A creditor can lose patience. That is what they count on, I think. Nothing by itself is enough to make a person listen." Jonah examined the dates and asked her to show him which notices came from the bank and which from the Rusk ranch. She had already sorted them. The careful arrangement made him think of the clerks he had worked beside years earlier, people who could find a lie in a ledger because someone had carried a figure into the wrong column. He told Martha that her notes were worth more than she knew.