Clara did not arrest anyone that day. She first met Mrs. Sloane, then interviewed Martha, the Vosses, and the other witnesses separately. She wanted dates, original documents, and statements that could be checked. She took particular care with the children, asking what they had seen without suggesting the answers. Anna described Clay's horse, rifle, and words. Will said that he remembered the loud noise and Daisy falling, but not the exact words. Daniel remembered the bell. Clara wrote their accounts separately because differences were not necessarily lies, and truthful memory rarely arranged itself with the neatness of a rehearsed story.
Her second day was spent at the bank. Fenner received her politely and asked for a formal request before opening confidential customer books. Clara supplied the proper documents and arranged with Holt for further legal process where required. The records she was allowed to inspect showed that several loans had been assigned, extended, or declared overdue in ways the bank needed to explain. One notation on the Bell account was written in ink unlike the rest of the page. She did not accuse Fenner of forging it. She asked who had made the entry and where the supporting authorization was kept. Fenner's answers grew less certain as the questions became more specific.
At the ranch, Silas Rusk watched the investigation from behind polished windows. He ordered his foreman to inventory cattle and instructed his bookkeeper to bring all purchase files to the office. The ranch had legitimate business enough to fill several ledgers: wages, feed, freight, breeding stock, land taxes, and sales to eastern buyers. Among those ordinary transactions were the purchases now under examination. Silas knew how to explain most of them. He had made offers; owners had signed; money had changed hands. What worried him were the conversations that had occurred before the signatures, the threats he had permitted Clay to make, and the credit arrangements Fenner had treated as routine.
Clay was less patient. He believed that if Jonah disappeared, the inquiry would lose the person holding it together. He failed to understand that Jonah's greatest contribution had been making the evidence independent of him. The originals remained with their owners or public offices, the sworn statements with Creed, and the state investigator had begun her own work. Clay still imagined the affair as a contest between men. He could not understand a contest in which the opponent refused to be the center of the story.
On the third morning of Clara's visit, Jonah rode the county road beside Martha's pasture to meet a surveyor at the disputed crossing. The wind was sharp, and frost rimmed the weeds. Three horses waited near a stand of cottonwoods: Clay's black gelding and the two mounts belonging to Wade and Ellis. Jonah saw them early enough to stop before they blocked the narrow road. Clay sat with his rifle across the saddle. The hired hands kept their revolvers holstered, but their horses were turned outward in a way that left Jonah little room to pass.
"You have been digging in my family's papers," Clay said. Jonah answered that county records belonged to the public. "You have brought a state woman into our business," Clay continued. Jonah said the investigator had been asked to examine evidence supplied by several families and the county prosecutor. Clay laughed without pleasure.