She asked whether she might sweep the porch, weed the flowerbeds, or help with cleaning in exchange for instruction. Caldwell's mouth tightened. 'I teach students whose families take the work seriously,' he replied. Nora said she would take it seriously, but he interrupted. 'Seriousness requires the right environment. You cannot develop proper technique by pretending to play on a table.' He spoke as though he were explaining a simple law of nature, then added, 'There is no piano for you here.'
Nora walked home in an icy drizzle that soaked through her socks. She did not cry on the hill because she had to pass the houses of children who knew her from school. She cried when she reached the back steps and found Ruth peeling potatoes in the kitchen. Her grandmother listened without interrupting, even when Nora repeated Caldwell's words in a voice that barely held together. Then Ruth put down the knife and drew the girl toward her chair.
'People with doors like that sometimes forget they didn't build the whole world,' Ruth said. Nora wiped her face on her sleeve and asked what she was supposed to do if the only door led to that house. Ruth thought for a while, watching a truck pass outside. 'Then we'll find you some boards,' she said, 'and you can start building one of your own.' She meant it partly as comfort, but Nora heard it as a plan.
That winter Nora made a notebook out of used paper and labeled it MUSIC, not bothering to decorate the cover. She divided the pages into scales, composers, musical terms, and questions she hoped someday to ask a teacher. She saved the dollar she earned carrying groceries for an elderly neighbor, then another dollar from helping Mrs. Ortiz straighten the library's sale shelves. She put the money in a glass jar behind the flour tin and wrote PIANO on a piece of tape across its lid. Some weeks she added nothing. She counted what was there anyway.
When her class discussed future careers, Nora said she wanted to be a pianist. Several children laughed, and her teacher, Mrs. Phelps, offered a strained smile. 'That's a lovely interest,' she said, 'but a profession in music takes a great deal of expensive preparation. You might think about a stable career like your mother's.' Nora felt every head in the room turn toward her. She looked at the teacher and answered, 'My mother works hard. I know that's honorable. It doesn't mean I can't do something different.'
The class went quiet. Mrs. Phelps apologized for being misunderstood, then moved quickly to the next student. Nora spent the rest of the day feeling as though she had been rude to a grown woman, though she could not find the rude part of what she had said. At home Elise listened