The Saloon Boss Offered $500 for the Cowgirl’s Ranch — Then She Asked Why Her Dead Father Was Still Paying Him

Chapter 20

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

But the name had stayed in Maeve's head, and 2 days later, she had written Gaffney a letter explaining the situation in careful, factual terms, and asking whether he would be available for a consultation. He had replied promptly. She made the trip to Rawlins on Friday. Gaffney was a compact man in his 50s with a neat office and the habit of making very brief notes on a small pad while someone was talking. He listened to Maeve's account without interrupting.

When she finished, he looked at his notes for a moment. " The ledger itself," he said, "its admissibility in any formal proceeding would depend on several factors. How it was obtained, whether it can be authenticated, whether the entries can be connected to actual transactions." He tapped his pen against the pad. " What you need to do immediately, if you haven't already, is preserve the original, document its condition, ensure it's stored somewhere secure, and that any copies are clearly identified as copies.

I've already done that. He looked at her with something that might have been mild approval. " Good. Second, authentication. For any entry you want to use, you need independent confirmation wherever possible.

Original agreements, receipts, company records. You've already done this with the freight charge?" Yes. " Written confirmation from the company. Keep building that.

Every entry you can independently confirm strengthens the ones you can't." He set his pen down. " What Rusk is doing questioning the ledger's origin and your competence to interpret it, that's the correct defensive strategy. He can't make the document disappear. He can make people uncertain about what it means.

Your counter to that is not to argue about the ledger. It's to produce independent evidence that makes argument unnecessary. What about the debt he purchased? The transferred obligation? " If it's a legitimate debt, genuinely owed and validly transferred, it's enforceable," Gaffney said plainly. "

Rusk holding it doesn't make it fraudulent. It just means you owe him rather than the original creditor." He paused. " However, if you can demonstrate that the amount claimed includes charges that were not part of the original agreement or that payments were made against the balance that were never credited. Those are things that affect the actual amount owed, not the existence of the debt.

The amount Maeve thought about the entries in the ledger. Several of them related to accounts similar to her father's. Payments received but not credited. Charges added above the original terms. If the amount claimed is inflated, she said, through charges that weren't agreed to, then the amount you legitimately owe is less than the amount being claimed, Gaffney said, and demonstrating that through original documentation is a valid, legal, and commercial argument.

She rode home from Rawlins with her thoughts moving faster than the horse. Jonah was at the fence line when she got back, replacing a post that had gone soft at the base. He was working with Pete and one of the younger hands, and the three of them had settled into a rhythm. Jonah setting the new post, Pete tamping the earth around it, the young hand managing the wire. She watched for a moment from the gate.

News in the same category

The Saloon Boss Offered $500 for the Cowgirl’s Ranch — Then She Asked Why Her Dead Father Was Still Paying Him

50 Part