Teacher Mocked a 12-Year-Old Girl for Crying at the Piano — Then Learned Who She Wrote the Song For

Chapter 6

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Lily sat at the grand piano and placed the score on the rack. She heard the paper clip fall onto the wooden floor and bent to retrieve it. Before she could sit upright, Dr. Whitmore said, "Do take your time. Our schedule is apparently less valuable than yours." Laughter traveled along the back row. Lily's cheeks burned, and she carefully set the clip beside the score instead of trying to fasten the pages again. She wanted to disappear into the floorboards, but she had already promised Ms. Park she would try.

Dr. Whitmore began asking questions before Lily could play. Why had she chosen to write rather than learn a recognized piece? Had she consulted a published harmony text? Had she ever attended a professional recital? Lily answered honestly, saying she used the academy library, listened to recordings, and studied what Ms. Park had taught her. The teacher nodded as if confirming a suspicion. "So you have very little formal background, but you imagine yourself a composer. Confidence is certainly abundant these days."

Brooke raised her hand without waiting to be called. "Dr. Whitmore, can students use the Young Artist Grant for clothes?" The teacher looked puzzled. Brooke continued, smiling at Lily. "I was wondering because some people might need that before they need private lessons." A few children laughed before they could stop themselves. Dr. Whitmore did not tell Brooke to apologize. She merely said, "We are not here to discuss personal finances," in a tone that made it sound as though Lily had brought the subject into the room.

Lily stared at the black keys. She knew Brooke was waiting for her to cry, and she refused to give her the satisfaction. But Dr. Whitmore had one more remark ready. "At Bellmont, a scholarship purchases an opportunity to learn, not an exemption from the expectations that paying families meet. You are fortunate to be here, Lily. Gratitude is most convincing when it is accompanied by preparation." The sentence struck harder than Brooke's joke because it came from the person responsible for evaluating her work. Lily wondered whether the teacher had already decided what she would hear.

"May I begin?" Lily asked. The room fell quiet in surprise at the steadiness of her voice. Dr. Whitmore raised one eyebrow and waved toward the keyboard. "If you insist. But please remember that this is a piano class, not a theatrical audition." Lily looked at the first three notes, the little question her mother had once taught her, and inhaled slowly. She pressed the keys with the gentle touch she had practiced in their living room. The sound rose into the still air, fragile and familiar, and for four measures nobody moved.

News in the same category

Teacher Mocked a 12-Year-Old Girl for Crying at the Piano — Then Learned Who She Wrote the Song For

20 Part