Teacher Mocked a 12-Year-Old Girl for Crying at the Piano — Then Learned Who She Wrote the Song For

Chapter 4

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Park asked her to play it again more slowly so they could examine the way her hands moved. She had a firm manner and refused to accept sloppy rhythms, but she never mistook unfamiliar training for a lack of ability. For the first time outside her living room, Lily understood that criticism could be offered without making a child feel small.

After eight months of steady progress, Ms. Park recommended Lily for the academy's intermediate piano studio. The promotion came with opportunities to perform for visiting musicians and to apply for a larger award that could cover private instruction. It also placed Lily in Dr. Celeste Whitmore's class. Dr. Whitmore had once been a respected touring pianist and now supervised Bellmont's most visible student performances. Her photograph hung outside the recital hall beside those of several generous donors. She was skilled and demanding, and she believed strongly that serious music education should look and sound a particular way.

On Lily's first Saturday in the new class, Dr. Whitmore examined the old blue folder and asked whether she had proper printed editions of her assignments. Lily explained that Ms. Park had allowed photocopies from the academy library. "That might be acceptable in the introductory program," Dr. Whitmore said, "but here we teach children who intend to become musicians." The difference between those two statements stayed with Lily for the rest of the day. She began asking Rosa not to wait with her in the hallway, afraid other families would notice her grandmother's work shoes and the name of the cleaning company stitched on her jacket.

Rosa noticed the change anyway. She had raised two daughters and knew the difference between ordinary shyness and the kind that came from anticipating humiliation. One evening she found Lily trying to scrub a pale scuff from her shoes with a toothbrush. The girl insisted the mark was distracting, though the shoes had been perfectly clean earlier. Rosa set a towel on the table and sat beside her. "I can help with the shoes," she said. "But if somebody has made you believe the shoes are the important part of a music lesson, I want to know about it."

Lily wanted to explain. She wanted to tell her grandmother about Brooke Ashford, who sometimes arrived with a new dress just for a Saturday rehearsal, and about the two boys who mocked the small keyboard she used for practice. She wanted to say that Dr. Whitmore corrected her mistakes in a louder voice than anyone else's and called her "our scholarship girl" instead of using her name. But Rosa already worried about money, and Lily feared that a complaint might cost her the place she loved. She said only that the work was harder now. Rosa kissed the top of her head and answered, "Hard work is what you came for. Being hurt is something else."

News in the same category

Teacher Mocked a 12-Year-Old Girl for Crying at the Piano — Then Learned Who She Wrote the Song For

20 Part