Teacher Mocked a 12-Year-Old Girl for Crying at the Piano — Then Learned Who She Wrote the Song For

Chapter 5

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Brooke had not always been openly cruel. At first she had treated Lily as an interesting inconvenience, asking why she traveled by bus and whether her grandmother was "the person who cleaned the church." Then she began making jokes whenever other students were listening. She called Lily's blue folder a bargain-bin portfolio and told another girl that the scholarship had probably been invented so Bellmont could advertise how generous it was. Lily avoided answering because any protest would draw Dr. Whitmore's attention. The silence made Brooke bolder, until the jokes became part of the room's ordinary background.

Lily took the answer to Ms. Park, who asked to see the score. They sat in a practice room while Lily played only the opening, stopping before the part that had come from her mother's illness. Ms. Park studied the notation, then asked why Lily had stopped. "Because I don't know whether it's good," Lily said. Ms. Park considered that for a moment. "Good is too small a word for what we are measuring. Some of this is beautifully observed, and some of it needs work. If you want to perform it, we can work on it together without changing the reason you wrote it."

On the Friday before the assessment, the academy emailed a reminder that students should wear concert clothes and bring their printed music. Lily's best dress was the navy one Rosa had altered for a cousin's wedding, and she wore it with a pale cardigan because the weather had turned cold. Rosa pressed the dress carefully, then laid it across Lily's bed. "Your mother wore that color," she said, smoothing one sleeve. Lily nodded without lifting her eyes. Rosa waited, then added, "Whatever happens tomorrow, you do not have to earn the right to remember her."

The next morning Lily arrived early and sat outside Room Four with her folder in her lap. Families drifted past carrying coffee and bouquets. Brooke's mother, Caroline Ashford, wore a silk scarf that probably cost more than Rosa earned in a week. She stopped to greet Dr. Whitmore and spoke loudly about the private master class she had arranged for Brooke during spring vacation. When her gaze fell on Lily's dress, she smiled politely but looked away almost immediately. Lily watched the clock and told herself that she only needed to play her piece and get through the day.

Inside the room, the assessment began with scales and short prepared performances. A dozen students sat in folding chairs while several parents watched from the wall. Dr. Whitmore invited Brooke first, praising her confident appearance before a note had sounded. Brooke played an elegant selection and received a warm round of applause. When the second performer stumbled, the teacher gave him a chance to start again. Lily listened carefully, trying to remember that this was a class and not a trial. Her hands were cold despite the heated room.

When Dr. Whitmore called Lily, she glanced at the blue folder and frowned. "I see you have brought your little composition after all." Lily nodded and stepped forward. "Ms. Park helped me prepare the notation," she said, hoping that would reassure her. Dr. Whitmore's face tightened at the mention of another teacher's name. "Then perhaps Ms. Park has been too generous with her encouragement," she replied. Several students shifted in their chairs, but Brooke smiled openly, as though a promised entertainment had finally begun.

News in the same category

Teacher Mocked a 12-Year-Old Girl for Crying at the Piano — Then Learned Who She Wrote the Song For

20 Part