“Yes.”
“Two dollars?”
“No.”
“How much?”
“None of your business.”
She laughed.
Howell sighed.
“They’re clearing multiflora rose near the east pasture.”
“Good.”
“I still hate them.”
“You’ll get over it.”
“No.”
“Then hate them accurately.”
He stared.
“What does that mean?”
“They aren’t cattle.”
“I’m aware.”
“Don’t manage them like cattle.”
Howell looked toward her.
For a moment Margaret thought pride would stop him.
Then he asked:
“What should I do?”
That was the first time he ever asked her advice.
She gave it.
Not for money.
Not because he deserved a favor.
Because bad livestock management punished animals before it punished pride.
Howell followed enough of her advice that most of his goats thrived.
He never became a goat farmer.
Twelve became eighteen.
That was enough to clear brush his cattle ignored.
The valley began changing its mind.
But cheese changed it faster.
Margaret’s cheeses improved over the second year.
She settled on three styles.
A fresh soft cheese sold quickly in spring and summer.
A firmer salted wheel aged for several months.
And one smaller hard wheel she aged longer in the root cellar, turning it every few days, brushing the rind, and recording everything.
That cheese became her obsession.
The milk changed through the season.
Early spring milk carried the richness of new growth.
Summer brought clover, blackberry leaves, herbs, and dry hillside browse.
Late summer milk became heavier.
Margaret learned to blend morning and evening milk for consistency.
She learned which strong-flavored plants needed to be limited just before milking because too much of some browse made the milk unpleasant.
Wild mustard fascinated her.
A little seemed to add something she could not name.
Too much ruined everything.
She adjusted pasture rotations partly by taste.
Aaron found that ridiculous.
Then he began doing it too.
“North paddock tomorrow,” he said one evening.
“Why?”
“Milk tastes sharper.”
Margaret stared.
“You mocked me for saying that.”
“I have evolved.”
“You ate a goat-chewed shirt.”
“That changes a man.”
By the second autumn, Walter Ames could sell every wheel Margaret brought him.
Then a hotel kitchen thirty miles away ordered twelve.
The cook wanted more.
Margaret refused.
Aaron stared at her.
“Why?”
“We don’t have milk for more.”
“Breed more goats.”
“Then we need more browse.”
“Lease land.”
“Then we need more fencing.”
“So?”
“So growing faster than the farm can support is how people end up owing Howell Briggs money.”
Aaron became quiet.
That was enough.
They grew slowly.
They paid cash when possible.
The cabin still leaned in storms.
The tractor still needed persuasion.
Margaret’s apron still had patches.
But the thirty-one dollars beneath the floorboards became forty.
Then ninety.
Then two hundred.
One evening Aaron brought the old money box to the table.
“Count it.”
“I know what’s in it.”
“Count.”
Margaret did.
Three hundred eighteen dollars.
She looked up.
Aaron smiled.
“That is more money than we had when you bought the goats.”
“By three hundred nineteen dollars.”
“Your arithmetic is wrong.”
“I paid two.”
Aaron laughed.
For the first time, the future felt larger than the next bill.
That was when the county announced the agricultural exhibition.
Bitter Creek held livestock competitions every year, but the county commissioners wanted to expand the event. Butter. Preserves. Bread. Cured meats. Cheese.
Three judges would score farmstead cheeses on texture, aroma, rind, consistency, flavor, and finish.
Winner: fifty dollars and a supply contract consideration from two regional merchants sponsoring the event.
Walter Ames entered Margaret’s cheese without asking.
She found the form beneath his counter.
“What is this?”
“Your entry.”
“I did not enter.”
“I did.”
“You can’t.”
“I checked.”
“You checked what?”
“The rules.”
“Walter.”
“Best cheese in my store.”
“You sell four cheeses.”
“Then statistically you have excellent odds.”
Margaret took the paper.
“I’m not competing.”
“Why?”
“Because Howell will be there.”
Walter blinked.
“That is your reason?”
“No.”
“What is your reason?”
Margaret looked at the form.
For two years, valley people had laughed at the goats.
Then they stopped.
But the laughter still existed somewhere inside her.
She could hear Caldwell’s stockyard whenever she failed.
Every bad cheese.
Every dead goat.
Every broken fence.
Every time she wondered whether Howell had been right about the land.
Walter leaned closer.
“You’re afraid they’ll laugh again.”
“No.”
“Margaret.”
She looked at him.
“Yes.”
Walter nodded.
“Good.”
“Good?”
“Means you finally know what you’re deciding.”
He slid the form back.
“Not whether your cheese is good.”
“Whether you’re willing to hear somebody say it isn’t.”
Margaret took the entry home.
She left it on the table overnight.
The next morning, she signed.
The competition took place in the county courthouse because the agricultural hall roof had been damaged by spring winds.
That was how, two years after Margaret paid two dollars for thirty-seven half-dead goats, a pale wheel of her aged cheese ended up beneath three knives in the same building where men discussed taxes, deeds, livestock liens, and property sales.
More than a hundred people waited outside.
Margaret wished they would leave.
Aaron stood beside her.
Widow Pruitt came too.
Nathan was thirteen now.
Taller.
Healthier-looking.
Still skinny enough that Margaret threatened to feed him personally every time he worked through supper.
Howell Briggs entered a cheese produced by a dairy operation partly financed by his brother.
That irritated Margaret less than she expected.
Howell approached.
“Nervous?”
“No.”
“You’re lying.”
“Yes.”
He smiled.
“I tried yours last month.”
Margaret stared.
“Where?”
“Ames’s store.”
“You paid?”
“Of course.”
“How much?”
“Too much.”
She smiled.
“What did you think?”
Howell took his time.
“Good.”
That was all.
Coming from Howell, it might as well have been a speech.
The judges began.
They did not know which farmer made which cheese.
Entries were numbered.
Margaret’s was seven.
Judge one cut into the wheel.
The paste was smooth ivory, firm without being dry.
Judge two smelled it.
Judge three bent the slice gently between his fingers.
Margaret could hear every tiny movement.
The first judge tasted.
No expression.
The second.
Nothing.
The third chewed longer.
Margaret’s hands tightened around her apron.
Aaron whispered, “Breathe.”
“I am.”
“Not visibly.”
“Stop talking.”
The judges moved to entry eight.
Margaret almost collapsed from the release of tension.
Scoring continued another hour.
When the chairman finally walked outside with the results, people crowded toward the courthouse steps.
Margaret stayed near the back.
She did not want to stand where everybody could watch her lose.
Nathan grabbed her sleeve.
“Come on.”
“No.”
“Mrs. Doyle.”
“Nathan.”
“You made me carry cheese here.”
“That does not give you authority.”
He pulled anyway.
The chairman read honorable mentions.
Third place.
Not hers.