She Paid $2 for 37 Goats Everyone Called Worthless — Two Years Later, Three Judges Cut Into Her Cheese and the Whole Valley Fell Silent

Chapter 2

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Margaret did not make promises about goat milk curing anything.

She filled a jar.

“Take this.”

Mrs. Pruitt held out the flour sack.

“I brought apples.”

“Keep them.”

“We have enough.”

“So do we.”

Both women knew that was not true.

They compromised.

Half the apples.

Half the milk price Margaret would normally have asked.

Over the next months, Mrs. Pruitt came twice a week.

Sometimes she paid.

Sometimes she brought eggs, apples, sewing work, or labor.

Nathan drank the milk, but what changed his appearance was not some miracle hidden in goat dairy. Mrs. Pruitt began eating better too because Margaret found small jobs she could pay her for. Nathan worked around the barn after school. Aaron repaired their stove pipe. Margaret sent cheese scraps home whenever she had them.

By the following summer, the boy’s cheeks looked fuller.

The valley later turned that into another legend.

They said Margaret’s goat milk healed Widow Pruitt’s sick child.

Margaret corrected anyone who repeated it in front of her.

“He needed food.”

That was the truth.

The first cheese was terrible.

Margaret knew it before Aaron tasted it.

He cut a slice.

Chewed.

Stopped.

Margaret waited.

“How bad?”

Aaron looked thoughtful.

“Do I have to answer as your husband or as a customer?”

“Customer.”

“Then I would like a refund.”

She snatched the plate.

“What’s wrong with it?”

“Sharp.”

“It’s supposed to have character.”

“It has several.”

“Too salty?”

“Yes.”

“Anything else?”

“Texture.”

“What about it?”

Aaron tapped the slice against the table.

It made a sound.

Margaret stared.

He pushed the plate away.

“Maybe we build a house with it.”

She laughed despite herself.

The next wheel was softer.

Too soft.

The third developed a crack.

The fourth smelled wrong.

Margaret threw it out without tasting it.

Cheese was not magic either.

Her Wisconsin childhood had taught her principles, not a recipe perfectly suited to milk from recovering goats eating Appalachian-style hill browse in a valley thousands of miles from where she had learned.

She had to relearn.

Clean milk.

Consistent temperature.

Good cultures.

Correct curd development.

Enough draining.

Right salt.

Proper aging.

The Doyles did not own a cheese cave.

They owned a root cellar cut into the north side of a hill.

Margaret cleaned it completely.

Whitewashed the walls.

Built wooden racks.

Tracked temperature.

Hung wet cloth near the entrance in hot periods and adjusted ventilation when humidity climbed too high.

She kept notebooks.

September 18: too much salt.

September 25: curd cut too large.

October 2: better. Aaron ate second slice voluntarily.

October 16: rind uneven. Cellar too damp after rain.

November 4: good flavor. First one I would sell.

When Margaret sold her first wheel to Walter Ames, who ran the general store, she charged forty cents.

He put it beside cheddar from a regional dairy.

Nobody bought it.

After three days, Walter cut samples.

One customer bought a wedge.

Then another.

A week later he ordered two more wheels.

“How much?”

Margaret asked.

“Same price.”

She stared.

“No.”

Walter raised an eyebrow.

“Why?”

“I know what it costs me now.”

“So?”

“So forty cents is stupid.”

Walter smiled.

“How much?”

“Sixty.”

“For goat cheese?”

“Then buy cheddar.”

He paid sixty.

The farm did not transform.

That would have been easier.

The first year with goats was nearly as difficult as the year before.

They needed fencing.

Minerals.

Shelter repairs.

Veterinary care.

One buck escaped and destroyed half Margaret’s fall garden.

Three goats learned how to open a poorly latched gate.

Aaron threatened to sell all thirty after finding them on the cabin porch eating laundry from a basket.

“You said they ate weeds!”

“They’re flexible.”

“One ate my shirt.”

“It was an old shirt.”

“It was my good work shirt.”

“You own one good work shirt?”

“I did.”

He pointed toward the goat.

“It is currently leaving.”

Margaret laughed until she had to sit down.

Aaron tried not to.

Failed.

Slowly, the goats became his too.

He built better gates.

Improved the milking stand.

Turned an unused section of barn into a clean dairy room.

When Margaret complained that lifting filled milk cans hurt her back, he designed a small wheeled platform so she could roll them.

The man who once stared longingly at a sixty-dollar dairy cow stopped talking about cows.

Then the drought deepened.

The following summer arrived hot and dry.

Howell Briggs watched his pastures turn brown.

By July, he was hauling hay from another county.

The price rose every week.

His cattle remained valuable animals, but valuable animals consume feed whether grass grows or not.

The Doyle goats browsed farther up the hill.

Not without limits.

Margaret supplemented them too.

They needed water.

They needed minerals.

They could not live on woody stems indefinitely just because popular stories liked imagining goats could digest fence posts.

But the Doyles possessed forty acres of vegetation cattlemen had spent decades considering inferior.

In a drought, inferior forage became useful forage.

Howell noticed.

He stopped his horse beside their fence one afternoon.

Margaret was moving goats into a patch of brush.

“You’re clearing that?”

“They are.”

“Going to seed grass afterward?”

“Maybe clover in places.”

“You could run cattle eventually.”

“No.”

Howell frowned.

“Why not?”

“Because then I’d need cattle.”

He looked toward the goats.

“You’re really keeping them.”

Margaret smiled.

“I own that many gates now. Can’t waste them.”

Howell did not laugh.

He had offered to buy the Doyles’ forty acres three times.

The first offer came after Aaron’s father died.

The second after the Doyle barn roof partially collapsed.

The third came a month before the goat auction.

Each time Howell described it as mercy.

“You two are trying to make a living on ground that doesn’t want to be farmed.”

Margaret had begun thinking about that sentence differently.

Maybe Howell’s mistake was assuming there was only one definition of farming.

He saw grass that would not carry cattle.

Margaret began seeing leaves at goat height.

He saw rocks a plow could not cross.

She saw soil she did not have to plow.

He saw thistle as failure.

Her goats saw breakfast.

That autumn, Howell came again.

This time he offered twice what he had before.

Aaron whistled when he heard the number.

Margaret remained quiet.

Howell looked toward her.

“You know that’s generous.”

“I know.”

“You could buy eighty acres somewhere flatter.”

“Maybe.”

“Good cattle ground.”

“We don’t own cattle.”

He frowned.

“You could.”

Margaret looked toward the barn.

Nathan Pruitt was carrying a milk pail toward the dairy room.

Mrs. Pruitt sat on the porch wrapping cheese for market.

Thirty-three healthy goats browsed behind the upper fence now. The herd had grown through kidding and careful breeding, though Margaret had sold several animals rather than expand beyond what the land could support.

Aaron asked quietly, “What do you think?”

Margaret looked at him.

“Do you want to sell?”

He considered it.

A year earlier, he might have.

Now he shook his head.

Howell stared.

“You’re turning down good money for weeds and rocks?”

Margaret smiled.

“That’s what they were when you made the first offer.”

He rode away irritated.

The following spring, Howell began experimenting with goats himself.

He told nobody.

Margaret found out because his hired man came to Walter Ames’s store and bought three bags of mineral mix Margaret had ordered.

She said nothing.

That restraint lasted six days.

Then Howell stopped beside her mailbox.

“I bought twelve.”

Margaret pretended confusion.

“Twelve what?”

“You know.”

“Cows?”

His face hardened.

She smiled.

“Goats?”

News in the same category

She Paid $2 for 37 Goats Everyone Called Worthless — Two Years Later, Three Judges Cut Into Her Cheese and the Whole Valley Fell Silent

5 Part