Mattie pulled out the chair beside her and sat. That's the right question, she said. And the answer is that right now it's decided by whichever party has the money to bring it before a court. The law, as written, depends on measurement and documentation. To have any force, you need a surveyor who can measure the flow before and after the diversion.
You need that measurement on record. Prudence looked at her notes. So the law protects you if you can prove it. If you can't prove it, it's just a paragraph. That's most of the law, Mattie said, which is why documentation matters.
Numbers on paper, dated and witnessed, are worth more in a courtroom than any number of people saying what they saw. Prudence wrote that down, not as an assigned note, as something she wanted to remember. Mattie moved to Susanna. Susanna had finished the arithmetic assigned and had turned her paper over and was writing something on the back, not a lesson. Mattie looked at it without touching it.
Words, a paragraph, neat and complete, in handwriting significantly better than children twice her age. Mattie read it. It was a description of the valley, the way it looked after the storm, the blue sky, and the white ground, and the mountains to the west. Four sentences, each one precise and particular. Nothing wasted.
Mattie looked at Susanna. Susanna looked back at her, waiting. This is good writing, Mattie said. Susanna looked at the paper. The third sentence, Mattie said.
You wrote that the snow was like salt on a clean table. That's an image. Do you know what I mean by that? Susanna shook her head slightly. It means you made me see the thing you were describing by comparing it to something else.
That's harder than it sounds. Most people just say what something looks like. You said what it felt like to look at it. Mattie paused. Keep doing that.
She went back to the head of the table and let them work. After the lesson, she was washing the noon dishes when Susanna came into the kitchen and stood by the table. Mattie turned around. Susanna was holding something out. A small carved figure, pine, pale and smooth, worked down to a clean shape, a woman, standing straight, holding something in both hands that resolved, when Mattie looked at it closely, into a rifle held at rest across the front of the body.
The figure's feet were planted. The posture was solid. Around the woman, barely suggested by a few carved lines, was a flock, sheep, or maybe cattle. Small shapes ranged around the standing figure. Mattie looked at it for a long time.
She took it carefully from Susanna's palm. "This is me," she said. Susanna looked at the figure. "You made me a shepherd," Mattie said. Susanna looked up.