She had a talent for moving through the house without announcing herself, and took her seat at the end of the table, and arranged her paper and pencil with careful precision. Prudence came last with mercy, balanced on her hip. Mattie looked at Prudence. "Put the baby in the crib. You need both hands for this."
Prudence raised an eyebrow. "She'll cry. Let her cry a little. She's 10 months old, not made of glass." Prudence looked uncertain, then went and put Mercy down.
Mercy expressed her opinion about this. Prudence came back to the table and sat, and Mercy's opinion gradually diminished to a murmur and then stopped. Prudence looked at the ceiling, then at Mattie. "She's fine," Mattie said. She found her fist.
Prudence let out a breath and picked up her pencil. Mattie taught Jonas's letters first, going through the morning primer lesson at his end of the table, while the others worked on their own tasks. He was at the stage where reading was starting to shift from an impossible thing to an almost possible thing. That narrow window where a child begins to see that the marks on the page have a logic, that they aren't arbitrary, that they mean something consistent every time. When that connection happens, there's a specific look on a child's face.
Mattie had been watching for it. She saw it that morning about 30 minutes in when Jonas sounded out a three-letter word for the third time and then looked up at her with his eyes wide. It says the same thing, he said. Every time, she said. He looked back at the page with the particular expression of someone who has just been handed a key and is still figuring out the size of what it unlocks.
She moved up the table to Enoch. He was working through arithmetic long multiplication with a grudging competence that told her he was better at numbers than he wanted to admit. He'd gotten an answer wrong and was erasing it, pressing too hard, nearly breaking the chalk. Ease up on the slate, she said. I know how to hold chalk.
Then show me because right now you're fighting it. He looked at her. Did the problem again? Got it right. She didn't make a remark about it.
She just moved on, which was the right response. Enoch didn't need praise. He needed to know the standard and be left to meet it in his own way. Prudence was working through a section of territorial civic law on water rights, making notes in the margin of her paper in a neat, precise hand. Mattie stopped behind her and read over her shoulder.
What's your question? Mattie asked. Section 4, Prudence said without looking up. It says upstream diversion for agricultural use is permitted provided it doesn't materially reduce downstream flow. Who decides what materially means?