Gideon Thorne and his children may remain on the Broken Wheel property as working guests while the parties negotiate terms. No legal claims may be pressed or acted upon during this period. Both parties sign. Both parties are bound. He looked up.
Acceptable? Mattie said yes. Gideon said yes. The judge wrote the clock on the mantle ticked. The fire in the stove settled.
Mattie looked at the silver pocket watch, still sitting on the table. She reached out and picked it up. It was heavier than she expected, solid and real in her palm. She turned it over. The Broken Wheel engraved on the back was the same design as the brand she pressed into her cattle.
The same mark on the sign over the ranch gate. Two watches. Same mark. Two brothers who'd never formerly been brothers. one buried in the cold ground and one sitting at her kitchen table because a letter and a child's need for warmth had brought him here. She set the watch down in front of Gideon.
He didn't pick it up immediately. He looked at it. Then he looked at her. "Judge Sterling will need it as part of the documented evidence," she said. "You can have it back after."
He nodded. The judge finished writing. He blotted the page and turned it around, and each of them signed where he indicated. Mattie with her own pen from the sideboard drawer. Gideon with the pen the judge offered.
Sterling folded his copy carefully and tucked it into his satchel. He left the second copy on the table. I'll be back through in January, he said, standing and collecting his coat. I'd encourage you both to have a clear proposal by then. The county court is not a process that benefits small ranchers, either of you.
He looked at them over his spectacles one last time. Work it out between yourselves if you're able. People who've done honest work on honest land generally can. He let himself out. Mattie and Gideon sat at the table after he'd gone.
The wagon sounds in the yard faded. A log shifted in the stove. She picked up Thomas's letters again. She untied the wax string fully this time and spread them out flat and read through all three of them one more time slowly because she'd learned years ago that it's better to understand a hard thing completely than to understand it halfway. Half understanding leaves gaps where old stories can creep back in.
Gideon didn't say anything. He drank his coffee. He waited. When she finished, she stacked the letters and looked at them sitting there on the table. Three letters.
Eight years of a weight she'd carried for nothing. She thought about the yellow door at the end of the hall. She'd painted it with hope. A room waiting for a life that was never going to arrive. Not the way she'd imagined it.