She held his gaze. Every one of those was a choice. And you made all of them. So did you, he said.
I know, she said. But yours cost you something, too. Your reputation, the legal action, the risk to this ranch. She paused.
I don't want you to think I don't see that, Clara. He said, I know you see it. I've never once thought otherwise. She held his gaze for one more moment.
Then she picked up the stack of arithmetic papers, pulled a blank sheet from the bottom, picked up her pen, and began to write the first letter. Nathan went to the kitchen and made supper. And he listened to the scratch of her pen from the other room. And he thought that this this specific arrangement of sounds, her pen and the stove and the wind outside was the sound of his life being what it had not been for a very long time.
Complete. The twist came on a Tuesday in December, and it came from a direction Nathan had not been watching. He was in town for supplies when Gerald Hatch pulled him aside at the feed store with the expression of a man carrying something that had been burning his pocket. There's a man been asking about Clara Whitmore, Gerald said.
Last two days, not one of Ashford's people. I know their faces now. Different, older, well-dressed. Gerald lowered his voice.
He went to Margaret first, said he was family. Nathan went still. What kind of family? He said he was her father's brother.
Nathan's jaw tightened. Her uncle is in Helena under cooperation terms. He's not allowed. Not that uncle, Gerald said.
He said he was the other one. Thomas Whitmore had two brothers apparently. This one said his name is Robert Whitmore. He's been in San Francisco for 15 years.
He came east when he heard about the case. Nathan stood with that for a moment. Clara had never mentioned a second uncle. Never once in all the conversations about her family, about her father, about what had happened after Thomas Whitmore died.
Either she didn't know or she had chosen not to mention it, and he didn't know which of those possibilities unsettled him more. He drove back to the ranch faster than he usually did. Clara was at the kitchen table with her students work when he came in. She looked up at his face and put the papers down. "
What happened?" She said. He told her watched every word land. She went very still. "
Robert," she said. The word came out different from her usual speech softer and then immediately harder, like she'd felt something and then decided how she was going to feel it. " Robert Whitmore." " You know him," Nathan said. "