She's really here voluntarily. She wants to be here. She fixed two fence posts yesterday and organized my accounts ledger this morning without being asked. Nathan said, "If that's not voluntary, I don't know what is."
Something shifted in Margaret's face. " People have been unkind," she said. " It wasn't a question." " People have been talking about someone they've never met," Nathan said. "
I'd appreciate it if the next conversation in town sounded a little closer to what I just told you," Margaret straightened. " It will," she said. She said it the way a woman says something when she has decided it is going to be true. " I'll see to it." "
Thank you, Margaret." She climbed back into her wagon. Then she paused, looked back at him. " She should come to town," Margaret said. "
Letting people only hear about her makes it worse. If they see her a real person, not a rumor, it's harder to say the things they've been saying." " I'll mention it," Nathan said. He went back inside and set the peaches on the kitchen shelf and thought about what Margaret had said.
Then he went to find Clara in the barn. She was brushing December with long even strokes, talking to the horse in a low voice. The way some people talk to animals, without self-consciousness, without performing the talking, just using the words like a tool to keep her own mind from going somewhere she didn't want it to go. She heard him come in and kept brushing.
Town, she said before he could speak. You're going to say I should go to town. How did you? I was listening from the side door.
She glanced at him. I'm sorry. I'm not used to not knowing what's being said about me. He came and leaned against December's stall.
Clara kept brushing. You don't have to. He said it was a suggestion. No, she said.
Margaret Olds is right. A rumor lives in the space where the truth isn't. If I stay out here and hide, I'm filling that space with nothing, and people will fill it themselves. She stopped brushing.
I've spent enough of my life being defined by other people's versions of me. I'd like to try being defined by myself for a change. Nathan looked at her. December turned her head and regarded them both with the mild indifference of a horse who has heard a great deal and kept it all to herself.
When Clara said, Saturday, Nathan said there's a market day. Most of the town will be out. Good, Clara said. Then most of the town can see me at once, more efficient.
He almost smiled. You're not afraid. She resumed brushing. I'm terrified, she said.