Mostly he felt tired.
This was still the same woman who had once brought him banana bread after pneumonia.
The same neighbor whose patio heater he had helped move.
The same person who waved while checking mail.
People prefer villains who were obviously villains from the beginning.
Real life is less cooperative.
Sometimes a person is ordinary for years before fear, greed, or opportunity reveals what they are willing to justify.
Before Marjorie moved, she asked to speak with him.
Her attorney had already resolved the property-damage portion involving Evan’s studio. He had no reason to agree.
He did anyway.
They stood near the fence between their backyards on a cloudy afternoon.
Without her carefully styled hair and work clothes, Marjorie looked older than fifty-five.
“You still paint the Cavanaugh house?” she asked.
“Sometimes.”
She nodded.
“I never hated the paintings.”
“I know.”
“You know now.”
“Yes.”
Her eyes moved toward the studio.
“I thought you were doing it on purpose.”
“What?”
“Painting the crate. My car. The North Star worker.”
Evan stared at her.
“You thought I was investigating you?”
“I thought Helen might have told you something before she died.”
He almost laughed.
“Helen and I talked about tomatoes.”
Marjorie looked confused.
“What?”
“She gave me tomatoes every August. That was about the depth of our conspiracy.”
For the first time, shame crossed Marjorie’s face without defensiveness behind it.
“When I saw the April painting, I recognized the evening.”
“Of course you did.”
“The window was still there.”
“Yes.”
“Peter’s worker had come to measure.”
“Yes.”
“And the estate notice was visible.”
“Yes.”
She closed her eyes.
“All that time…”
“You thought the painting accused you.”
“Yes.”
“It didn’t.”
She opened her eyes.
“Not until you destroyed it.”
That landed.
Evan let the silence sit.
Then he asked the question that still bothered him most.
“Why fake the break-in?”
Marjorie looked toward Helen’s old house.
“I had already sold the lanterns.”
Before the police report.
Before the stained-glass panel was removed.
She explained slowly.
Helen had once discussed selling some household items to help cover home-care expenses. Marjorie took that conversation and stretched it far beyond its meaning. After Helen died, she convinced herself she was only moving faster than the estate. She sold the lanterns. Then the sconces. Told herself the money could be accounted for later.
Then a buyer offered forty-six thousand dollars for the Hadley panel.
That changed the scale.
Maya was in Colorado.
Gregory had not completed the formal inventory.
Marjorie believed she had a short window of uncertainty.
Then she learned an appraiser was coming.
“I needed an explanation for why things were gone,” she said.
“So you damaged the side door.”
“Yes.”
“And called police.”
“Yes.”
“You created a theft to explain a theft.”
She flinched.
“When you say it like that—”
“How else do you say it?”
She had no answer.
Then she whispered, “I thought if the items were listed as missing before the inventory, nobody could prove when they disappeared.”
That was the heart of it.