So Evan assumed she was being protective.
“Paint the park,” she said.
“I do.”
“The church.”
“I have.”
“Your own garden.”
“That sounds terrible.”
“Evan.”
Something in her voice made him stop smiling.
“What?”
“Leave that house alone.”
Then she walked out.
A week later, Evan came home at three twenty in the afternoon and found the studio door open.
He knew something was wrong before he stepped inside.
A landscape of the river lay facedown on the floor.
One frame leaned broken against the wall.
Paint tubes had been knocked from the worktable. A glass jar full of brushes had shattered near the sink, blue-handled flats and sable rounds lying among glittering shards.
For one stupid second, Evan blamed the wind.
Then he saw the knife marks.
Three canvases had been slashed.
Two had been smeared with dark oil paint.
A garden study had been stepped on hard enough to break the stretcher.
The April sunroom painting was gone from its rack.
He found it inside a black trash bag under the workbench.
The canvas had been cut out of the frame, folded twice, scraped with a palette knife, and smeared across the center until the stained-glass window disappeared under a dirty streak of black paint.
Evan stood holding the remains of it while his pulse hammered in his ears.
Then he looked around.
His laptop was still on the desk.
Camera equipment untouched.
Cash in the drawer.
Nothing valuable missing.
Whoever had entered had not come to steal.
They had come to erase.
He checked the security camera.
At 1:47 p.m., Marjorie Sutton walked through his side gate.
No mask.
No hat.
No attempt to hide her face.
She looked once toward Evan’s house, then opened the studio door and went inside.
The interior camera captured everything.
That was the part that made his stomach turn.
Marjorie did not begin by destroying.
She searched.
She moved finished canvases away from the wall, turned each toward the light, checked the backs, and placed some aside carefully. She ignored a portrait commission. Ignored three river studies. Ignored a painting of the old Methodist church.
Then she reached the row containing Helen’s house.
Her movements changed.
Faster.
One canvas.
Look.
Another.
Look.
A third.
Then the April eighteenth painting.
She stopped.
Her fingers tightened around the frame.
For six seconds, she stared at one small area near the lower right side.
Then she carried the painting to the worktable, picked up Evan’s own palette knife, and cut through the canvas.
After that, she destroyed the others almost frantically, as if she suddenly realized she did not know which painting contained the thing she was afraid of.
Evan watched the footage twice.
Then he called the police.
He did not knock on Marjorie’s door.
He did not send a text.
He did not give her a chance to explain.
That decision mattered.
Officer Renee Alvarez arrived twenty-five minutes later.
She was forty-one, compact, calm, and had the expression of someone who had spent enough years responding to suburban disputes to know that expensive landscaping did not make people reasonable.
She watched the security video in silence.
Then she looked around the studio.
“Estimate on damage?”
“I don’t know.”
“Hundreds?”
“More.”
“Thousands?”
“Probably.”
She nodded and wrote something down.
“Do you know why she did it?”