Then Thomas noticed the teddy bear in Martin Hale's hands. Mud stained the fur, one seam had split, and a tire track crossed the faded blue ribbon. His expression tightened for a different reason.
"That's Emily's bear," he said.
Dean's anger finally showed. "You remember her, then."
Thomas did. Everyone over forty in Carver remembered Emily Sullivan's illness because the town had held two blood drives during her treatment. Mayor Danner had visited the hospital once when he was still a councilman. He had forgotten the toy run's history because forgetting had become politically convenient. He had not forgotten the little girl.
Rick looked between them. "Dad, don't start taking their side."
The mayor's head turned slowly. "Their side?"
"They're the problem. This whole biker circus is the problem. You said yourself the developers hate this kind of thing downtown."
A murmur moved through the crowd.
Thomas closed his eyes for half a second. It was enough. Dean saw the mistake before the mayor spoke.
"I said the developers wanted a cleaner commercial presentation," Thomas said. "I did not tell you to destroy charity property."
"Same difference."
"No. It isn't."
The mayor walked toward the crushed toys and bent down to pick up a small plastic dump truck with one wheel broken off. Snow collected on the shoulders of his coat. For years he had convinced himself that the Winter Iron permit was an administrative nuisance, not a betrayal. Standing in the wreckage of toys purchased for children, the argument looked smaller than it had behind a desk.
Rick still refused to yield. "He punched me first."
Dean said, "You threw my daughter's bear in the mud."
"That doesn't give you the right -"
"No," Dean interrupted. "It doesn't. I hit you. I'll answer for that. Are you going to answer for the rest?"
That question did more to quiet the square than any threat could have.
Deputy Price was beginning to understand how badly he had handled the first minute. He walked to the VFW entrance and asked three people separately what they had seen. Their accounts matched. Rick had provoked Dean, thrown the bear, and been punched. The fight followed. Then, after Dean was cuffed and no longer a threat, Rick had deliberately backed his truck through the toy pile and into the motorcycle.
Price returned to Dean and unlocked one cuff, then the other. "Stay here," he said.
Rick stared. "What are you doing?"
"Correcting something."
"My father is the mayor."