Criminal mischief in Ohio, the intentional destruction of someone else's property, can be a misdemeanor or, depending on damage value, a felony. My camera housing, combined with the internal unit that was damaged when she torqued the bracket, totaled $412 in replacement parts. Just over the $400 threshold that bumps it from a minor misdemeanor to a first-degree misdemeanor. Not a coincidence that I kept my receipts. Brenda's response to the criminal complaint was to immediately deny everything, which was interesting given the footage, and then within the same week to initiate a smear campaign.
She sent an email to the HOA's full listserv, 214 households, claiming that I had installed illegal surveillance equipment that was recording her without consent when she was simply performing her duties. She used the phrase "invasion of privacy"three times in an HOA email about a camera mounted on the outside of my own house pointed at my own driveway. The reply all responses started coming in within minutes. Some were supportive of Brenda. Form follows function.
People protect their tribe. But a surprising number were not. Trudy Voss from the meeting fired back almost immediately. Brenda, are you seriously claiming privacy rights on someone else's driveway? Chuck Dolan sent a single sentence.
I have outdoor cameras, too. Am I next? Brenda's email had accidentally done what I'd been carefully trying to build for 2 months. It had made this everyone's issue. Dale called me that night.
I could hear him smiling through the phone. She just gave us our class action foundation. If she's claiming your cameras are illegal, she's implicitly threatening everyone who has cameras. That's community-wide harm. That changes everything about how this case gets framed.
I looked over at Colleen across the kitchen table. She was reading the email chain on her laptop, one eyebrow raised, shaking her head slowly with the expression of a woman who has been proven right about something she wished she'd been wrong about. She just poked the whole hive, Colleen said. Yeah, I said. Good.
Three days after Brenda's listserv meltdown, Dale called me from his office. I could hear the rustle of papers, the faint tap of his keyboard, and said, "Garrett, I have been doing some digging into Brenda's background, and you are not going to believe what I found." Dale had subpoenaed the HOA's financial records as part of a formal records request under Ohio's non-profit corporation law, which governs most HOAs. He'd been looking for documentation of the emergency session that had levied my fines, meeting minutes, a quorum count, anything that would confirm the procedural violations we already suspected. He found that, but he also found something else.
The HOA collected monthly dues from 214 homeowners. The dues had been raised twice during Brenda's tenure, first from $180 to $210 per month, then from $210 to $240. Across 214 homes, that's roughly $615,000 per year flowing into the HOA operating account. Standard stuff