The smell of wet leaves thick in the air. His lab mix snuffling at the mailbox post. And said, "I heard what she's doing to you. Same thing happened to the Petrovsky family two years back. She had them fine for their Christmas lights every single December."
I hadn't known about the Petrovskys. I started asking around. Over the next two weeks, I discovered that in the 26 months of Brenda's presidency, she had sent formal notices to, I counted, 31 of the neighborhood's 214 homes. That's roughly 15% of the neighborhood. A remarkable enforcement rate for violations like basketball hoops, holiday lights, and potted plants on front steps.
More interestingly, I mapped the addresses. 26 of the 31 homes were in the eastern half of the community, the section built in the late 1990s. Slightly smaller lots, slightly older homes, slightly more diverse mix of residents, slightly more blue collar. Brenda lived on Cresthaven Drive in the western half. Where the homes were newer and the lots were larger.
I gave that map to Dale. He looked at it for a long time and said, "This is selective enforcement. Potentially discriminatory selective enforcement. This is significant, Garrett." Meanwhile, Brenda organized what she called a community safety forum, a neighborhood meeting ostensibly about the car burglaries.
I attended. So did about 40 of my neighbors. The air in the community center smelled like burnt coffee and carpet cleaner. And the folding chairs squealed against the linoleum every time anyone shifted. Brenda stood at the front of the room and, without a single trace of irony, presented a slide deck recommending that residents install HOA compliant security measures.
She showed a picture of a Ring doorbell, the original lowest resolution model from 2018, and called it the approved type. She had invented this approval on the spot without a functioning architectural control committee, without a board vote, without anything. A woman in the back raised her hand. " Isn't Garrett Whitfield's system better than that?" Brenda's smile tightened like a rubber band being stretched. "
Mr. Whitfield's installation violates community standards." The woman in the back, I later learned her name was Trudy Voss, and I could have hugged her, said, "But there are three streets in the western half where I can count at least six cameras. Did any of those get fined?" Brenda moved on to the next slide without answering. I did not say a word.
I sat in the back row, drank my bad coffee, and felt something I hadn't felt in 2 years of dealing with this woman. Momentum. That night, Colleen and I talked for a long time at the kitchen table. She was scared about the lien, and honestly, she had every right to be. A lien on your house is not abstract.