HOA Karen Smashed My Security Camera — Then a Deputy Watching the Livestream Called It In

Chapter 4

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

I went back inside. I pulled up section six, clause one. The inspection right applied to common areas and community structures, not individual homeowners' driveways, not private property. She had just made that up, or more likely, she was betting I'd never check. I went back to Dale.

Dale said, "Keep the footage. Don't confront her again. And Garrett, go back and read section nine, clause two, one more time. The specific word I'm thinking about is unapproved. Look at the surrounding context."

That night I pulled up the CC&Rs on my laptop, opened a beer, and sat at the kitchen table until 11:30 p.m. reading HOA documents. Colleen brought me a blanket and didn't say a word. After 22 years of marriage, she knows the look. She kissed me on the top of the head and went to bed. At 11:47 p.m., I found it.

Section nine, clause two, prohibited the installation of unapproved surveillance equipment. Not all surveillance equipment, unapproved. And who had the authority to approve security installations. Per the parent clause, section 9, clause 1, the architectural control committee, a three-member body appointed annually by the full board. I scrolled back through three years of HOA meeting minutes, which I'd requested in bulk under Dale's advice, and which had been dumped on me in a disorganized PDF.

It took me 40 minutes, but I found what I was looking for. The last architectural control committee had been appointed in February 2020. Their one-year term had lapsed in February 2021. No renewal appointment had ever been made. The architectural control committee, the only body with legal authority to approve or deny my cameras, hadn't legally existed for nearly two years, which meant there was no one who could have approved my cameras, which meant they couldn't be unapproved, which meant section 9, clause 2, was legally unenforceable against me.

I closed my laptop, finished my beer, and went to bed, smiling for the first time in months. I let that nugget of legal gold sit untouched for three weeks. Dale's advice? Patience. " The worse she behaves before we move,"he told me, "the better our position when we do."

Brenda did not disappoint. The first week of November, I got a notice that the HOA was filing a formal lien against my property for the unpaid $2,000 in camera fines. A lien on my house for security cameras. The letter was delivered by a process server, which means Brenda had hired an attorney, or at least was using the HOA's retained legal firm, and it informed me that the lien would accrue interest at 12% annually, and could ultimately affect my ability to refinance or sell. Here's something most people don't know.

In Ohio, an HOA can file a lien, but a lien based on improperly levied fines, fines assessed at an improperly noticed meeting, is itself challengeable. Dale was practically rubbing his hands together at this point, but we weren't ready to challenge anything yet, because something else was happening simultaneously, something I hadn't expected. The neighbors were talking. Word had gotten around that Garrett Whitfield was fighting the camera ban. My neighbor three doors down, a retired postal worker named Chuck Dolan, stopped me in the driveway one gray Saturday morning.

News in the same category

HOA Karen Smashed My Security Camera — Then a Deputy Watching the Livestream Called It In

15 Part