Ella continued repainting plant labels whenever weather faded them. She eventually replaced her first hand-lettered stakes with small uniform markers approved by the new committee, and she was surprised to discover she liked the cleaner look. Mateo never developed an interest in hydrology but became the person adults trusted to move bags of mulch without being asked twice. The project remained theirs in memory, but it stopped belonging only to them in practice.
That was another change Noah had not expected. During the fight with Diane, ownership had become emotionally important because every time she said HOA property, she used the phrase to make the children sound temporary. After the rebuild, Noah gradually understood that common property really did belong to everyone in a complicated way. His contribution mattered precisely because the rain garden did not remain his private thing.
Cal's crew maintained it. Paula's committee reviewed it. Residents complained about it. Peter evaluated it. Children observed it. Mrs. Alvarez watched water leaving it. The board paid for it. Nobody had the right to say, "Mine," including Noah.
That realization softened one of the memories that had bothered him most: Diane telling Lucy the plants were HOA landscaping. She had been right about the ownership and wrong about what ownership allowed her to do. The truth did not belong entirely to either side.
The board's formal one-year review happened in June, almost exactly twelve months after Marcus had first pulled the consultant report from an old folder. This time the agenda item was not called Kids' Rain Garden, a change Noah noticed immediately. It read HAWTHORNE STORMWATER BED - YEAR ONE PERFORMANCE AND MAINTENANCE REVIEW. The title made the project sound less personal and, to Noah, more secure.
Peter Sloan joined by video again and presented a short summary. Moderate-rain nuisance ponding had been reduced compared with the limited observations available before the pilot. The redesigned basin was draining within the expected window. The curb inlet still required periodic cleaning, and Peter recommended keeping that task on the annual contract rather than assuming plants would compensate for neglect. He also reminded the board that no one year of data guaranteed future performance.
The treasurer asked the question that would have seemed impossible during the first summer. "What does this cost us compared with just putting lawn back?" Cal had prepared numbers. Routine maintenance of the rain garden was somewhat more expensive than mowing grass but less expensive than repeatedly replacing sod and washed mulch at the low spot. The more significant cost was periodic inlet cleaning, which Cedar Glen should have been doing anyway. None of the figures made the project free, and none made it absurd.
A resident who had once supported Diane's boxwood plan asked whether the HOA was now committed to native landscaping everywhere. Paula Greene answered no. The stormwater bed was functional landscaping at a specific drainage site, not a neighborhood-wide aesthetic policy. Another resident asked whether children would continue maintaining it. Marcus said children were welcome to help under supervision, but responsibility belonged to the HOA and its contractors. Noah was relieved to hear that stated so plainly.