Linda opened by asking everyone to avoid personal attacks. "This is not a trial," she said. "We are reviewing committee authority, property damage, contractor direction, and a drainage-related modification to common property." A man in the back whispered that it sounded exactly like a trial. Rachel heard him and almost smiled.
Management began with the timeline. The board had approved the rain-garden pilot four to one. The original authorization covered the small planting area, adult grading, child participation, labels, mulch, and rainfall monitoring. The consultant's interim note later recommended keeping the pilot through fall. The board had voted four to one again to do exactly that. No subsequent board vote had authorized removal.
Diane raised her hand. "The committee retained maintenance authority over common landscaping." The management representative nodded. "Routine maintenance authority, yes. Not unilateral authority to terminate a board-approved pilot or alter a drainage grade." Diane opened her binder. "The work order says cleanup and regrade."
"A work order you initiated outside management," Linda said. Diane answered that committee chairs had historically instructed landscaping vendors directly for minor work. Cal shook his head from the side row. "Minor work means trim shrubs, replace mulch, fix edging. You asked my company to add material to a drainage low point after I told you it changed grade. When I refused, another crew was called."
Diane turned toward him. "You are a landscaping contractor, not the board's engineer." Cal did not react to the insult. "Correct. That's why I told you to get management and engineering approval." The simplicity of the answer caused a few residents to shift in their seats.
Linda asked Marcus to summarize the consultant recommendation that had existed before the children's project. He read from the old report: clean curb inlets, evaluate selected swales, and consider a shallow rain garden or bioretention planting at the Mud Corner to reduce nuisance ponding and improve infiltration. Diane listened without expression. Marcus then read the diagram note warning against filling the low area without reviewing downstream conveyance.
"You received this report?" Linda asked. Diane said every committee member had received it. "Did you read it?" She hesitated for less than a second. "I reviewed it at the time."
Noah saw Rachel glance at Ben. There it was, one of the pieces the adults kept calling important. Diane could not say no one had told her the low point mattered. She could still argue about what she thought the warning meant, but not whether it existed.
Peter Sloan, the consultant, spoke next. He was careful enough to frustrate both sides. The storm had exceeded the moderate events documented during the pilot. The partly clogged curb inlet contributed materially to the sidewalk ponding and runoff toward Mrs. Alvarez's driveway. The preexisting drainage problem was real. The children's rain garden had not been designed as full flood protection.