Peter Sloan nodded before anyone else could respond. "It shouldn't be placed entirely on your shoulders." Diane turned toward him, surprised. He continued, "The inlet blockage and storm intensity mattered. The drainage problem existed before you changed the site. But your modification removed temporary storage and altered surface flow. Multiple causes can be true at the same time."
That answer prevented the meeting from becoming a public execution. Several residents who had supported Diane visibly relaxed because the consultant was not pretending she had caused the weather. Yet the same balance made her remaining defense harder. If the board could acknowledge what she had not caused, then what she had caused stood more clearly.
A homeowner asked why appearance should not matter at all. "We pay dues partly because we want common areas maintained," he said. "Some of us did think the garden looked bad." Lucy whispered to Noah that he was mean, but Noah shook his head. The man was not insulting the children. He was stating a preference shared by more residents than Noah liked.
Linda answered that appearance did matter. The new proposal from the consultant included cleaner edges, grouped native plants, fewer species, and a defined stone inlet partly because the original pilot could be made easier to maintain and easier for residents to understand. "The lesson here is not that every messy planting is good," she said. "The lesson is that functional infrastructure cannot be altered by aesthetic preference without the required review."
Diane seized on the admission. "So we are rebuilding it differently." Linda said yes. "Because review happened. That's the difference."
Noah realized then that Diane had been partly right about one thing: the original garden could be improved. Months earlier, he would have treated that as a threat. Now he saw how insisting the children had designed something perfect would make him sound like the adult version of Diane-insisting on a conclusion because it belonged to him.
Linda asked whether Noah wanted to speak. He had not planned to. Rachel leaned toward him and whispered that he did not have to. He looked at the broken rain gauge under his chair, then carried it to the front table.
The clear cylinder was taped where it had cracked. The numbers were still visible. Noah set it down without looking at Diane. "I know the garden wasn't perfect," he said. He paused because his throat had tightened. "That's why we were measuring it."
No one interrupted him. "We changed things when Cal said to. We were waiting for fall because the engineer said to wait. If it didn't work, then fine. If it needed different plants, fine. But you didn't wait long enough to find out whether it worked."