HOA Karen Demolished My Grandfather's Water Tower — Then I Found Their Water Line Crossing My Land

Chapter 5

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

On the way out, she caught up with me in the parking lot. The gravel crunched under our feet. The air smelled like pine resin and cold asphalt, that particular October night smell that means winter is thinking about showing up. She stood close enough that I could see the small American flag pin on her lapel, the kind of prop that certain kinds of people use to suggest patriotism is a personality trait. Garrett, she said smiling, I didn't know you were back.

I'm back, I said. " I hope you understand we were just trying to maintain community standards." " I understand completely," I said. " I'll see you at the hearing."

The objection letter Renata filed was 14 pages long and included three exhibits. It formally documented the lack of due process in the demolition, introduced the stormwater easement issue as a related matter, and, this was Renata's particular touch, filed a concurrent complaint with the state's HOA oversight board, which in Colorado has real teeth. Here's the second legal beat. Most states have HOA oversight boards or ombudsman offices that receive formal complaints. Filing with them creates an official record and often triggers mandatory mediation, which forces the HOA to respond on the record, which means every overreach is documented.

Takeaway. A state HOA complaint costs nothing to file and creates leverage you can use in court. Claudette's response to the oversight board was filed by her own attorney, a local real estate lawyer named Sheridan Price, who, I would later discover, had also served as the notary on two of Hargrove's original development documents. Small town, very small town.

Their argument was straightforward. The structure was noncompliant. The HOA acted within its authority under the community integration clause, and Garrett Thorn had been given notice. They submitted the single letter as their evidence of proper notification. One letter.

That was their whole case. Meanwhile, Walt Duvall had been quietly doing me a favor. A retired electrician with too much time and a genuine grudge because he'd also received a citation for his tool shed two months prior. Walt had started attending every HOA board meeting and recording them on his phone.

Not secretly. He sat in the front row with his phone face up on the table and told anyone who asked that he was keeping his own records. Claudette hated it. She tried to ban personal recording devices, but the HOA's own bylaws didn't support it. Those recordings were going to matter.

But first, I had to find out what was in Ridgecrest Commons water. Not metaphorically, literally. Here's something most people don't know about private HOA subdivisions built quickly on former agricultural land. The developer is responsible for the initial infrastructure hookup, including water service, and that hookup has to be certified by a licensed plumber and approved by the county utilities board.

It's boring paperwork. It almost never gets scrutinized. Almost. I'd been pulling documents for three weeks by this point. My dining room table had become a paper archaeology project.

News in the same category

HOA Karen Demolished My Grandfather's Water Tower — Then I Found Their Water Line Crossing My Land

15 Part