Second, the board conduct section. Renata, who I had invited to attend as my legal representative, which under HOA bylaws was a permitted role, presented the state oversight board complaint and its current status. Active investigation, mandatory mediation ordered. She presented the county letter, which she read aloud in full.
The demolition permit had been issued without proper review time. The county was initiating a review of the approval process. Claudette interrupted twice. Both times Birdie invoked bylaws. Both times she was correct.
Then came the structural section. The sealed surveyor's report on the clubhouse HVAC unit, 4 ft 2 in above the section 4.7 limit, the same section used to justify demolishing my grandfather's water tower. Renata stated it plainly. The enforcement had been selective, which under Colorado HOA law rendered the enforcement action against my property legally void.
The room, by this point, was making a sound I can only describe as the collective exhale of 60 people who have been holding their breath for a long time. Claudette stood up. Her voice, for the first time in any context I had observed, was not quite controlled. This is a coordinated attack on this community. This is a bylaw meeting, Birdie said.
Please sit down. The recall vote was the last item. Under the HOA bylaws, a two-thirds majority of present homeowners could recall any board member. The vote was conducted by paper ballot, counted by three volunteer homeowners in front of the room.
Claudette Voss was recalled by a vote of 54 to seven. She stood up, collected her binder, straightened her jacket, and walked to the door. She paused with her hand on the frame and looked back at the room. 60 people who had been her subjects for four years, who were no longer afraid of her, and then she left. The room exhaled again, longer this time.
Walt leaned over and said quietly, Your grandfather would have liked this. I think he would have. Vic Aldana was already writing. The photographer had gotten every moment, including Claudette's exit.
The story ran the following Thursday, front page above the fold. The headline, and Vic had a gift for headlines, was HOA, a president recalled after residents learn cost of community standards. It was, by a significant margin, the most read story in the Elkhorn County Courier's online history. Here is what happened in the six months after that Saturday morning. The county completed its review of Deputy Inspector Fowler's approval process and found three other permits he had expedited improperly over a four-year period, all connected to Hargrove-adjacent development projects.
Fowler resigned. Two of the three projects are under re-review. Claudette Voss did not face criminal charges for the reserve fund transfer. The amount was just below the threshold that triggers felony prosecution, but the state's division of real estate levied a $14,000 fine against the HOA and required a full, independent financial audit.