The smell of sage and warm earth came off the hillside, the way it always does in late September in Elkhorn, sweet and dry, and a little bit like something ending, which felt appropriate. The second call I made was to a property rights attorney in Denver named Renata Solis. I'd used her once before on a fence line dispute, and I knew she was the kind of lawyer who got quietly, methodically angry on behalf of her clients. I described what happened. She listened without interrupting.
When I was done, she said, Okay, first question. Do you have the original survey, the county registration for the agricultural fixture, and your certified mail receipt? Yes, yes, and yes. Then they just made a very expensive mistake.
Here's the first legal beat the audience should know. Under Colorado property law, and similar statutes exist in most states, an HOA cannot demolish a pre-existing, legally registered structure without providing written notice, a formal hearing opportunity, and a minimum 30-day cure period. Claudette's team had sent one letter, received one certified mail rebuttal, and then acted unilaterally. That's not code enforcement. That's trespass and destruction of property.
Takeaway, one letter is not legal process. Know the cure period requirement in your state. But here's what made it more interesting. Renata dug into the county filing on the demolition permit, and it had been issued by a deputy inspector named Fowler, who had approved the job in under 48 hours, which was, by county statute, physically impossible for a legitimate structural demolition permit.
The standard review period was 10 business days. Fowler had signed off in two. So we had HOA overreach, destruction of a registered structure, and a permit that may have been fraudulently expedited. I could have filed a lawsuit right then. Renata suggested I wait.
Let them think they won, she said. Let Claudette send you the bill. The bill? She's going to bill you for the demolition cost.
They always do. It's in the fine print of the community integration clause. Non-compliance structure removal costs may be assessed to the property owner. She's going to send you an invoice for about $6,000. I laughed.
First time I'd laughed in two days. The invoice arrived 11 days later, printed on HOA letterhead with a little Ridgecrest Commons logo in the corner, a stylized ridge line that looked, I noticed, nothing like the actual ridge outside my window. The invoice was for $6,200. It included a line item for structural remediation and another for community aesthetic restoration.
There was a cover letter from Claudette herself signed in blue ink that said, and I am quoting verbatim here, we hope this closes the matter and allows us all to move forward as a community. I made a copy. Renata made a copy. I framed the original. That document was going to matter later.
Then I went to the county assessor's office and pulled every document associated with the Ridgecrest Commons development, all public record, all technically boring and absolutely loaded with land mines. Here's what I found in two hours of file pulling. Prescott Hargrove's original development had been approved contingent on maintaining a shared storm water retention agreement with the older properties on the ridge, including mine. That agreement meant Ridgecrest Commons' drainage permit was tied to my land, specifically to the area where the water tower used to stand.