Nathan examined a draft letter. It referred to chronic deficiencies in reliability, responsiveness to direction, and willingness to support operational goals. There were no dates, examples, or previous warnings. A similar letter lay beneath it with another employee's name. "They've written these before telling the workers there's a problem," he said.
Arthur nodded. "The original version was created before the latest evaluation cycle. They asked supervisors to supply negative examples afterward."
"Did you?"
"I sent back actual performance records. I refused to invent anything." He lifted his cup without drinking. "Then they told me my records were incomplete. I was told to update them using a new scoring form. The questions were written so anybody who pushed back on a supervisor could be scored as unwilling to adapt."
Nathan wanted to photograph everything, but he stopped. "Are these company records you're allowed to give me?"
Arthur looked relieved that he had asked. "Some are documents I received as the supervisor. I'm not certain I should have brought them. I need to speak with somebody who understands confidentiality. I don't want to destroy a legitimate investigation by doing something foolish."
"Then don't give me what you're not entitled to share. Tell me what you witnessed. We can find other ways to verify it."
Arthur gathered the drafts again. A waitress brought eggs and toast neither man had ordered. She was a longtime friend of Arthur's and told them the kitchen had made too much food. The generosity embarrassed him. When she walked away, Arthur stared at the plate. "I keep thinking about my youngest," he said. "He finished nursing school last year. I told him if he saw something that might hurt a patient, he had to say so, even if somebody important disagreed. I said it like I knew how to live that way."
Nathan allowed a moment of quiet. "You still can."
"Maybe. But yesterday wasn't the first chance."
Arthur explained how the safety complaints had accumulated, beginning with a near miss on a conveyor and continuing through a chemical odor near the paint area. The company had fixed some problems promptly. Others had stalled, particularly when repairs required stopping equipment during a large order. A safety specialist named Dana Whitfield had submitted a report recommending additional inspections. Two weeks later she was transferred to a less desirable shift for what the director called operational alignment. Arthur had not seen a copy of the report since.
"There are people who know what happened," Arthur said. "Marla has copies of her own complaints. Pete has work orders. A shipping clerk named Leon Pierce kept emails because he was afraid somebody would blame him if a pallet dropped. The problem is they're all afraid. Some have mortgages. Some are sending money to parents. Some can't afford to miss a paycheck, much less take a risk like you did."