You sewed up a killer in a gorge because you decided he was worth saving. You looked at Silas Granger in chains and told a whole town they'd been strong the entire time and never known it. He shook his head slowly. I don't scare you. That's the thing.
I can't get past Clara. Everybody on this earth has been scared of me my whole life. And you looked at me and were never scared. Not once. Not for a single minute because you're not the thing to be scared of.
Clara put her hand over his, holding it against her face. You never were. The things to be scared of smiled soft and forged their papers quiet and let a whole town do their looking away for them. You rode down a mountain in broad daylight and said no out loud. That's the opposite of the thing to be scared of Luke.
That's the only thing that ever beats it. and Luke Mercer, who had not wept when he buried his horse, who had not wept when the bullet went through his side, who had spent 11 years teaching himself to feel nothing so that nothing could ever be taken from him again. Luke Mercer bowed his head, and his shoulders shook, and Clara Whitfield stepped into him, and put her arms around him, and held on the way. He had once told her to hold on, riding away from an auction block into the rest of her life. Stay, he said into her hair.
I know I got no right to ask it. I know you got a whole valley needs you down there. But God help me, Clara. I'm done fighting alone. I'm done wanting nothing.
Stay. Marry me. Build something on this mountain that isn't just one lonely man waiting to die. He pulled back and looked at her, and his eyes were wet and unashamed. Your daddy trusted me with the thing he loved most in the world.
Let me spend the rest of my life proving he was right. I'm not going to stay on this mountain, Clara said. Luke went still. And neither are you, she went on, and she was smiling now through her own tears. Because there's 30 families down in that valley who need somebody in their corner.
And there's going to be another Granger someday. And when he comes, I am going to be standing right in his path. And I am going to need a dangerous man beside me. Luke Mercer, the most dangerous man in the territory. A man whose name alone makes the next Silas Granger think twice.
She took both his hands. So, no, we're not hiding up here. We're going down there together, and we're going to build the thing my father wished he'd built a place where the frightened people finally have somebody who isn't afraid. You and me, the killer. The world was wrong about.