And the strangest thing happened in that square. Granger's deputies looked at the six old honest men and looked at the crowd. The whole town watching the way the town of Asheford had watched Clara sold and done nothing except this crowd was not looking at its boots. This crowd was looking at the deputies and a paid man's courage runs out fast when the crowd stops looking away. They stood down.
Judge Elias Alderman was a heavy old man with white side whiskers and tired eyes that had seen every kind of lie a courtroom could hold. and he did not rise when Clara was brought into his chambers. They tell me, he said, there's a girl on my steps hollering about murder and forgery with Luke Mercer bleeding beside her and six deputies I don't recognize holding my square. That would be you. That would be me, Clara Whitfield.
She set the book on his desk. My father was Henry Whitfield of Asheford. 6 days ago, he was murdered. 3 days after that, my stepmother sold me off an auction block to satisfy a debt my father never took, forged by the Asheford Land and Cattle Bank, which is owned by Silas Granger. She opened the book to the first page.
It's all here in my father's hand. Every forged loan, every stolen ranch, every man Granger paid, and three killings, including a neighbor named Amos Reed, murdered and made to look like a drunk, fell down a well. Her finger did not shake on the page. I kept my father's books for four years, judge. I can testify this is his hand.
I can testify to every figure in it. And there are six honest deputies on your steps and a whole town in your square and a dead man named Cole Deckard in a gorge two days back who was Granger's own hired killer. So I am asking you, I am begging you to do the one thing nobody in Asheford would do. Read it. Just read it.
Judge Alderman looked at her for a long moment. Then he looked at Mercer standing gray-faced against the wall with his hand pressed to his side. That true Mercer Deckard's dead by my hand in self-defense before witnesses. He shot my horse and put a hole in me first. Mercer met the old man's eyes.
I know what my name is worth in a courtroom judge. That's why I'm not the one holding the book. She is. Everything I say, you can doubt. Everything she says, she can prove.
That was Henry Whitfield's whole plan, and it was a good one, and it cost him his life, so I'd take it serious if I were you. Alderman drew the book toward him. He put on a pair of wire spectacles, and he began to read. The chambers went silent except for the turning of pages. Clara watched the old judge's face and she watched it change.