Grant met Lucy on the porch and carried her trunks without waiting for a servant. His careful courtesy reassured her somewhat, but she remained watchful. During supper she studied how he addressed Harriet, whether he interrupted, whether he treated her jokes as foolishness or affection. Grant realized he was under examination and answered questions with unusual patience. When Lucy asked what her sister did during the day, he told her about the repair shop and its growing clientele. "She has better judgment about machines than I do," he added. Lucy looked at Harriet. "That sounds like the sister I know."
The visit stirred memories Harriet had avoided. After her father's death, she had raised Lucy through a succession of rented rooms, teaching her to balance accounts and mend clothes while earning money wherever men would accept her work. At seventeen Lucy had been offered a place in a teacher's training program, but the fees were beyond them. Harriet had promised she would find a way. The marriage contract had seemed a bargain not just for a shop but for Lucy's future. Hearing her sister describe lessons and new friends made Harriet proud; it also reminded her of how much their lives had depended on a single decision at the Cheyenne lawyer's desk.
One evening Lucy found the old letter Harriet had written but never sent. She did not read it fully; a folded corner opened as she moved papers from a drawer, showing only the sentence, I am frightened of loving a man who has already promised to let me go. She put it back. Later she asked Harriet whether she was happy. The question arrived without preamble, as sisterly questions often do. Harriet looked toward the workshop where Grant was helping Amos carry a plank. "More than I expected," she said. "But I haven't quite learned what to do with it." Lucy told her happiness was not a debt that needed immediate repayment.
Lucy also brought news from Laramie. The creditor who had taken their father's shop, Edwin Clarke, had offered the property for sale after failing to turn it into a profitable mercantile store. The asking price was steep, and the building needed work, but the old forge and stone foundation remained. Harriet received the news with conflicting emotions. She had spent years dreaming of owning that place again. Now she had a workshop, customers, and a husband she loved in Wyoming. Buying the old shop would tie up money and perhaps require her to live away from Grant. Not buying it felt like abandoning her father's memory. For two days she found herself unable to think clearly about either choice.
Grant noticed before she told him. "You're looking at that wrench as if it offended your family," he said. She set it aside and explained Clarke's offer. Grant listened, then asked the question he was learning to ask first. "What do you want?" Harriet smiled sadly. "I wish I knew." He suggested they visit the property before making a decision. She feared he was offering to buy it out of gratitude. He replied that he was offering only the journey and his company. The distinction mattered enough for her to agree.