A Cop Kicked a Woman in the Courthouse Hallway — Then She Reached Inside Her Jacket

Chapter 8

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

At nine fifteen she entered courtroom three as a defendant. Her attorney stood beside her. Harlan, sitting in the gallery, watched without knowing that the quiet woman in the charcoal suit had been sworn in as his department's next chief a little more than an hour earlier. Evelyn had not told him, and the court proceedings had no reason to begin with her new appointment. She was there to contest an accusation. Whatever badge she now carried did not change the burden on the state to prove its case.

Harlan was called to the stand shortly after ten. He walked with his usual rolling confidence and raised his right hand without looking at Evelyn. Under questioning by Claire Whitcomb, he described a dangerous traffic stop involving a hostile driver who had ignored repeated commands. He said Evelyn reached quickly toward the glove compartment, struck his leg, and attempted to break free. His account was polished, delivered in the soft, weary voice of a man who wanted the judge to believe he had reluctantly used force. He even paused to say that every officer wanted to go home safely.

Daniel let him finish. Then he asked about the first thing Harlan had said at the window. Harlan remembered requesting a license. He did not remember asking whether Evelyn owned the car or mocking her work papers. Daniel asked whether he could point to any injury caused by the alleged kick. Harlan said the injury had not been severe enough to require treatment. Daniel showed him the medical report and asked why no injury appeared there. Harlan said reports did not always record every detail. The answers came smoothly, and for a few minutes Evelyn understood why so many defendants had accepted plea agreements rather than confront this man in court.

Then Daniel placed the maintenance record on the document camera. "Officer Harlan, you said your camera was broken before the stop. Is that correct?"

"It had a known malfunction," Harlan answered.

"This work order says the camera passed its functional test six days earlier. Were you aware of that?"

Harlan leaned forward. "Cameras can break twice."

"Of course. Did you report a second failure before you stopped Ms. Mercer?"

"I told my supervisor."

"Which supervisor?"

Harlan hesitated just long enough for Evelyn to notice. "Sergeant Delaney."

Daniel turned a page. "The first written report of failure is timestamped eleven forty-two that night, after Ms. Mercer was booked. Can you explain why?"

"We had other priorities," Harlan said. He glanced toward the prosecutor, who had stopped making notes. The judge asked him to answer the question directly. He repeated that officers did not always have time for paperwork. Then he described the city's equipment budget and how dangerous the streets had become, offering enough general complaints to avoid the specific discrepancy until Daniel moved on.

News in the same category

A Cop Kicked a Woman in the Courthouse Hallway — Then She Reached Inside Her Jacket

30 Part