Daniel studied her. "Most people who just got kicked in a courthouse would be a little less reasonable."
"I'm angry," she said. "Reasonable doesn't mean otherwise."
He smiled faintly, but then his expression changed. He had received a message from Claire Whitcomb. The prosecutor wanted to meet because her office had discovered that an important police record had not been included in the original disclosure. It was the automated vehicle-location history for Harlan's cruiser, which showed his car taking a route different from the one he had described. Daniel knew the discrepancy might not settle the case, but it raised questions about the reliability of his sworn account. Evelyn asked him to forward everything to the independent investigator and preserve the original message.
At Oakridge police headquarters, the atmosphere was less orderly. Officers gathered in small groups, murmuring about the new chief they had never met and the senior patrolman who might have assaulted her in a courthouse. Captain Haskins told reporters that the department was cooperating fully, then spent twenty minutes asking his staff who had authorized the release of the appointment. He was furious that the news had come from a credential wallet rather than his own office. More troubling, the city council had named Deputy Chief Simone Carter as acting authority over all matters connected to Evelyn's case. Simone had earned a reputation for insisting on paperwork that other commanders treated as optional.
Simone arrived at headquarters carrying a written directive and a security consultant's report. She ordered the preservation of Harlan's disciplinary files, patrol assignments, body camera logs, and supervisor communications. Haskins objected that the request was excessive. Simone said the scope came from the independent investigation plan and the evidence preservation notice, not from personal preference. She reminded him that destroying or altering records after notice could create separate legal problems. Then she asked why several complaint files listed in the department index appeared to be missing from the archive.
Haskins told her the records system was old. "Nothing works the way it should around here."
"Then we'll find out what does," Simone replied.
In the records office, a civilian clerk named Pilar Desai heard the argument through the wall. Pilar had worked for Oakridge for eleven years and knew exactly which cabinets contained old use-of-force reports. She also knew that some reports never reached the cabinets at all. When a complaint involved a well-connected officer, a supervisor sometimes asked her to mark it as a preliminary inquiry and place it in a temporary file. Later, those temporary files would disappear during routine document purges that nobody seemed to remember authorizing. Pilar had kept a private list of case numbers because she hated the feeling of watching information vanish. She had never shown it to anyone outside the department.
That afternoon she opened the bottom drawer of her desk and took out the list. It ran to seven pages. Some entries concerned minor complaints resolved appropriately; others referred to injuries, disputed searches, and missing property. Harlan's badge number appeared repeatedly. So did Captain Haskins's initials. Pilar hesitated before calling Simone. She had a son approaching college age and a mortgage that still frightened her every month. Telling the truth might cost her job long before anyone could promise to protect it. Yet the photograph of Evelyn on the courthouse floor had made the old excuses feel unbearable.