At the station she was booked on charges of resisting arrest, obstruction, and striking an officer. Harlan claimed that she had kicked his shin while trying to escape. Evelyn requested medical attention for bruising along her shoulder and wrist. The booking nurse documented the injuries, but the report described them as consistent with a struggle during a lawful detention. Nobody asked why there were no defensive injuries on Harlan. Nobody explained why his dash camera and body camera had stopped recording before he reached her window.
She called Daniel Foster, an attorney she had known since childhood, rather than announce her professional history to everyone in the building. Daniel was a public defender in Oakridge and could not automatically take a private case, so he referred her to a colleague and helped her understand the local process. When Evelyn later retained Daniel after he left the defender's office for a small independent practice, he insisted they treat her case as any ordinary defendant's case. That meant obtaining discovery, preserving evidence, and refusing shortcuts that might let the city dismiss the incident without addressing what had happened. Evelyn agreed. She also told the city hiring committee about the arrest in writing, because she would not accept a job built on a concealed conflict.
The committee nearly ended her candidacy. Mayor Richard Sloane, whose photograph hung in the public library and whose donors' names appeared on half the city's construction sites, argued that hiring a person currently facing criminal charges would humiliate Oakridge. Councilwoman Denise Walker asked why the charges had appeared precisely while Evelyn was in town. Another council member requested the arrest video, only to discover the cameras had supposedly failed. The hiring committee postponed its vote and ordered an independent review. The mayor called it a distraction. Residents who had filed similar complaints called it the first time anyone in city government had seemed interested in asking questions.
While the case moved toward trial, Evelyn began meeting people who had spent years living beneath Harlan's version of the law. The first was Imani Brooks, owner of a small beauty supply store on Fulton Street. Harlan had stopped Imani's nephew after he delivered the day's receipts to the bank, seized nearly nine thousand dollars as suspected drug money, and released him without charges. The department returned less than six thousand dollars after months of requests. Imani had kept a photograph of the counted cash and the bank deposit slip prepared that morning. Her nephew had been so shaken by the stop that he moved to Birmingham to live with his father.
The second was Leonard Price, a retired mechanic who had watched officers search a delivery driver's van outside his garage. Leonard had taken photographs because the driver was a regular customer and had asked him to call his employer. The next day, a code enforcement inspector arrived at Leonard's shop and issued a stack of citations for conditions the city had ignored for years. Leonard stopped taking photographs after that. When Evelyn asked him why, he pointed through his office window at a wall of family pictures. "You don't have to hurt me to make me afraid," he said. "You just have to make me wonder who you'll hurt next."