She returned home to find an unfamiliar white pickup parked by the gate. A young man in an orange safety vest stood beside the ditch taking photographs. He introduced himself as Cole Danner, a field supervisor for Prairie Valley Earthworks. He said he was documenting the condition of a structure the company had serviced many years earlier and had permission to view it from the road. Maggie asked who had requested the inspection. Cole hesitated. Then he said the office had received an inquiry from Everett Kline and was reviewing its files.
"I don't mind somebody looking from the public right-of-way," Maggie said. "But I'd like to know if anyone intends to enter my property."
"Nobody's going onto your land without arrangements," Cole replied. He looked embarrassed. "I didn't realize there was a disagreement."
"There may be," Maggie said. "I'm trying to figure out what happened to the water."
Cole glanced downhill toward the pale scar where the gully opened. His expression grew serious. "That isn't ordinary sheet erosion," he said. "Something's concentrating flow."
"That's what I've been saying."
The young man studied the bank again. He seemed about to offer more, then stopped himself. "I wasn't working here in 2004," he said. "But my uncle was the foreman on the road job. He still keeps records in the garage. I can ask what he remembers."
Maggie wrote down her phone number. "Please do. And if you find anything, call Aaron at the county too. I don't want a private argument about a public drain."
Cole nodded and left. As his pickup disappeared, Maggie had the uncomfortable feeling that the issue was growing beyond the little story she had initially told herself: a daughter honoring her father's unfinished investigation. There were now old contractors, county maps, landowners, and possibly public infrastructure involved. Every additional person introduced another explanation and another chance for a misunderstanding. She wanted the truth, but she was beginning to understand how expensive truth could become when it required several institutions to agree about the same ditch.
That weekend Eli came to fix a gate hinge. He found Maggie sitting in the machine shed with three maps spread across a workbench. She had marked the known pipe locations in blue, suspected ones in red, and the areas of observed runoff in pencil. Eli looked at the overlapping lines and asked whether she had started a detective agency. Maggie told him she was trying to understand the water and had not yet reached the part where she knew who was right.
"Good," Eli said. "Because knowing who's wrong is usually easier than knowing what happened." He lifted one of the maps. "See this line? Goes toward the old crossing by the orchard. There's a depression there that looks like a covered ditch. My uncle hauled gravel to a job on this road years ago. He used to say the county had found more buried tile than anybody expected."
"Could you ask him what job?"
"He's in Arizona. He'll tell me every complaint he's ever had about the weather before he answers, but yes." Eli put the map down. "You're worried about the bank too."
Maggie looked up sharply. "Who told you that?"