“I’m not.”
She rose.
“I’m leaving.”
Caldwell stared.
“Where?”
Hattie had no answer.
The silence betrayed her.
Grayson stood more slowly this time. “My cabin has a second room.”
Hattie turned.
“No.”
He nodded once.
“Fair.”
Caldwell laughed.
“There you are, Cade. She’s too proud even to take charity.”
Grayson’s eyes moved toward him.
“Good.”
The single word confused Caldwell.
Grayson looked back at Hattie. “There’s a widow named Martha Fenwick above the general store with a spare room.”
Hattie knew Mrs. Fenwick.
“She charges six dollars a week.”
“I know.”
“I can’t pay that.”
Grayson thought.
“Then work.”
Hattie folded her arms.
“For you?”
“For her.”
She waited.
“Martha has arthritis, hates cooking, and has complained for two years that nobody keeps her accounts straight.”
Hattie considered.
“You know a great deal about her.”
“She talks.”
A miner said, “Everybody knows a great deal about Mrs. Fenwick.”
The room laughed.
Hattie almost smiled.
Grayson added, “Ask her yourself.”
That mattered.
No arrangement through him.
No debt.
No assumption.
Hattie nodded.
“I will.”
Caldwell muttered something about fools.
Grayson looked toward him.
Hattie said, “Don’t.”
He looked back at her.
“Why do you keep stopping me?”
“Because every time you stand, people think I need you to frighten someone for me.”
Grayson glanced around.
Several men suddenly looked at their drinks.
He sat again.
“Understood.”
Hattie realized then that a frightening man willing to sit when asked might be rarer than a frightening man willing to fight.
Mrs. Fenwick did have a spare room. She also had an arthritic right hand, three rental properties, two mining shares she did not understand, and a filing system involving envelopes shoved into a tea tin. Hattie moved in the following afternoon after agreeing to cook supper five nights a week, maintain household accounts, and help with correspondence in exchange for the room and two dollars weekly. It was less money than Caldwell had promised, but for the first time Hattie possessed an agreement stated clearly before work began.
Caldwell paid only fourteen of the twenty-four dollars he owed. Hattie took the money, wrote a receipt noting ten dollars disputed, and told him she would return for the rest after consulting the justice of the peace. He laughed loudly enough for three customers to hear. Hattie made sure their names went into her notebook.
Bessie left Caldwell’s kitchen wrapped inside Hattie’s shawl. She carried the crock herself, although Grayson had offered to help move everything else. When she placed it on Mrs. Fenwick’s kitchen counter, she checked the starter twice before unpacking clothing. Bessie bubbled lazily beneath the cloth as if two years of humiliation had been irrelevant.
Grayson returned the next morning. He had washed, shaved, and changed from wolf skins into a plain brown coat that made him look marginally less like a creature from mountain folklore. Mrs. Fenwick opened the door, looked him up and down, and said, “If you tracked mud onto my carpet, I’ll charge you for every footprint.” Grayson removed his boots on the porch.
Hattie laughed from the kitchen. Grayson entered in wool socks, carrying a sack of flour under one arm and a jar of honey in the other. He set both down.
“I didn’t order those.”
“No.”
“Then take them back.”
He nodded.
“Could I order bread?”
Hattie paused.
“How much?”
“Forty loaves a week.”
Mrs. Fenwick nearly dropped her teacup.
Hattie stared.
“For what?”
“I supply four timber camps and two prospect crews.”
“Since when do mountain men buy forty loaves?”
“Since yesterday.”
Hattie narrowed her eyes.
“Are you inventing demand because you feel sorry for me?”
“No.”
Grayson took a folded paper from his coat.
“I bought bread from Caldwell every week.”
Hattie looked at the invoices.
He had.
Thirty loaves some weeks.
Forty-two others.
The prices were higher than Hattie expected.
“His bread?”
“Your bread.”
Hattie realized Grayson had probably eaten versions of her baking before without noticing because Caldwell usually served ordinary yeast bread or sourdough after Bessie had been fed hurriedly. Yesterday’s loaf had carried the full family flavor because Hattie prepared it for herself as much as customers. She looked at the order again.
“You want forty?”
“Fifty if it keeps.”
“It will.”
“What price?”
Hattie opened her ledger.
Grayson smiled.
“You calculate everything?”
“Yes.”
“Good.”
They spent twenty minutes working through flour, salt, honey, fuel, labor, and packaging. Grayson accepted Hattie’s first number too quickly, making her suspicious. She recalculated.
“I underpriced.”
“Yes.”
“You knew?”
“Yes.”
“Why didn’t you say something?”
“I was waiting.”
“For?”
“You to notice.”
Hattie glared.
Grayson looked almost amused.
“Thirty-eight cents a loaf,” she said.
“Forty.”
“Why?”
“Delivery.”
“You’re collecting them.”
“Then thirty-eight.”
Mrs. Fenwick watched from the doorway.
“You two could make a church picnic feel like railroad negotiations.”
Hattie took the contract.
Grayson left flour and honey because the first batch required supplies Hattie could not afford before payment. She insisted the cost be deducted from his first invoice. He agreed.
No charity.
That distinction mattered enough to make the bread taste different to Hattie.
The first fifty loaves consumed Mrs. Fenwick’s kitchen for an entire day. Hattie fed Bessie the night before, mixed dough before dawn, worked in batches, and discovered the small household oven could not produce more than six loaves efficiently at once. By sunset, her feet throbbed and flour coated the room.
Mrs. Fenwick looked at the cooling bread.
“You need a bakery.”
“I need money.”
“Same thing in America.”
Hattie laughed.
Grayson collected the loaves himself.
He counted them.
Hattie approved.
He paid.
She counted the money.
Grayson approved.
For six weeks the arrangement continued. Hattie worked for Mrs. Fenwick, baked for Grayson, took small orders from townspeople who heard about “Grizzly Cade’s crying bread,” and avoided Caldwell whenever possible. The nickname embarrassed her.
Nellie told her to use it.
“People will pay extra.”
“I’m not naming bread after a man crying.”
“Why not?”
“Because he’ll kill me.”
Nellie looked toward Grayson unloading flour outside.
“No, he won’t.”
“True.”
Hattie smiled.
She named it Abigail Sourdough instead.
The first week she earned nine dollars beyond her board arrangement. The second week brought eleven. By the end of two months, Hattie had saved seventy-three dollars, more money than she had held at one time since leaving Ohio.
Caldwell noticed.
He began telling customers Hattie had stolen his recipe.
That claim reached Hattie through Nellie, then reached Grayson through three miners who found the story hilarious. Hattie’s first instinct was anger.
Her second was documentation.
She wrote Abigail in Kansas asking whether family letters mentioned Bessie’s history, then remembered Abigail had died eight years earlier.
The loss reopened briefly.
Hattie instead wrote to her aunt Ruth Coulter in Missouri.
Three weeks later, a packet arrived.
Inside were two yellowed letters from the 1850s mentioning young Ruth Bennett, a divided starter, and instructions for “Bessie’s bread.”
Grayson read them with trembling hands.
One letter had been written by his mother.
Hattie had not expected that.
The page began, Dear Mrs. Coulter, I kept the little jar alive all the way to Fort Laramie despite Samuel saying I was carrying spoiled paste across the continent.
Grayson laughed.
Then he stopped.
The letter continued, thanking Abigail for teaching Ruth how to “make a household from whatever is left.”
Grayson touched the paper with one finger.
“I’ve never seen her handwriting this young.”
Hattie watched him.
“You can keep the letter.”
He shook his head immediately.
“It belongs to your family.”
“Your mother wrote it.”
“To your grandmother.”
Hattie thought.
“We could copy it.”
Grayson smiled.