"The court has received and reviewed a comprehensive record of internal affairs complaints filed against officers Voss and Pruitt over a period of 9 years. These records previously sealed under administrative order have been obtained through federal warrant and entered into evidence as exhibits 41 through 78. She looked up briefly at the gallery. The record documents 23 separate complaints. In every case, the complaint was closed without investigation within an average of 11 days.
In eight cases, the officer who filed the complaint was reassigned within 60 days of filing. The gallery was absolutely silent. The court further notes that the signatures authorizing administrative closure on 17 of these complaints belong to Lieutenant Barbara Crane of the Columbus Police Department's Internal Affairs Division. At the back of the room, two of Dana Kress's agents rose quietly from their bench and moved toward the side door. Naomi continued.
She was not performing. She was not dramatic. She simply read the record name by name, date by date, case by case in a voice that was steady and clear and gave every word exactly the weight it deserved and no more. The gallery listened the way people listen when they are hearing something they have long known to be true stated plainly for the first time in a room where it cannot be denied. When she finished reading, she set the document down.
The court will now view exhibit 79. Thomas Avery pressed a key at the clerk's station. The screens mounted on the courtroom walls came to life. The footage was 2 minutes and 40 seconds long. In the courtroom on screens large enough for every person in the gallery to see clearly, it was a different experience than watching it on a phone.
The details were sharper. The sound was cleaner. The faces were unmistakable. The gallery watched in complete silence. A woman in the fourth row, one of the victim families who had been following the case for months, pressed both hands flat over her face and did not move for the duration of the footage.
A veteran civil rights attorney in the gallery, a man who had spent 40 years in courtrooms and believed he had seen everything, gripped the bench in front of him and stared at the screen with an expression that had gone somewhere beyond anger into something older and colder and more resolute. The footage ended. Voss was looking at the table in front of him. His jaw was set so tight a muscle moved rhythmically in his cheek. His hands were flat on the table and perfectly still with the specific stillness of someone exercising enormous conscious effort to remain that way.
Pruitt was not there to watch it because at 8:47 that morning, Shane Pruitt had appeared at Dana Cress's field office with his personal attorney and requested a cooperation agreement. He had brought documentation. He had brought audio recordings. He had brought 3 years of text message records that he had preserved on an encrypted backup drive, which suggested that some part of him had always known this day was coming and had made quiet preparations for it. Naomi had been informed of this before she entered the courtroom.
She had read the summary that Cress's team prepared. She had set it aside and come to court anyway because the case did not rest on Pruitt's cooperation and she had not built it as if it did. "Officer Voss," she said. He looked up. His eyes met hers across the courtroom.
The room held its breath. You will have the opportunity to respond to this evidence in the course of these proceedings. That opportunity will be full and fair because that is what this court provides. She paused. Even when the people before it did not extend that same courtesy to others.
His attorney touched his arm. He looked away. The afternoon testimony ran 4 hours. Leon Briggs took the stand and was on it for two of them. He spoke in a steady, unhurried voice and looked at the jury when he spoke.
Not at Voss. Not at the gallery. Not at the attorneys. He looked at 12 citizens and told them what he had seen and what he had written down and what he had failed for 3 years to do about it. And the honesty of that last part was more damaging to the defense than anything else he said because it was the kind of testimony that cannot be coached.
At 4:55, Chief Judge Harold Sutton submitted his resignation to the federal district's administrative office. His statement cited personal health reasons. Dana Crest texted Naomi during the recess to Crane in custody. Sutton's cooperating. The union rep goes tomorrow.
Naomi read the message. Closed her phone. Walked back into the courtroom. Sentencing was set for 30 days out. Every seat in the gallery was already claimed.
Sentencing day arrived on a Thursday in late November, gray and cold. The kind of morning that arrives without apology and asks nothing of you except that you meet it honestly. The courthouse steps were crowded before 7:00 a.m. Not with protesters. The two opposing crowds of the trial's early days had long since resolved themselves, as crowds do, when the facts become sufficiently clear, into a single gathering of people who had come simply to be present for something they understood to matter. They stood in the cold with their hands in their pockets and their breath making small clouds in the air, and they waited.
Naomi arrived through the main entrance. She always did now. The courtroom was filled to capacity. Every bench claimed. Every press seat occupied.