He considered himself efficient. A burned barn accomplished the same result as a burned house, with considerably less legal consequence. A beaten foreman accomplished the same result as a dead one, and left a witness alive to spread exactly the right kind of fear to every neighboring homestead. He kept four hired men on his payroll for exactly this kind of efficient cruelty, chief among them a broad, humorless enforcer named Silas Cobb, whose particular specialty involved finding the precise humiliation that would break a family's resistance without ever crossing into the kind of violence a territorial marshal might feel obligated to actually investigate. Three years of that careful, calculated cruelty had claimed nearly every homestead along Cedar Hollow's Creek.
Only one family remained holding out against Garrick's increasingly aggressive offers by the autumn of 1885. Henry Voss, a widower who had built his modest bottomland spread with his own hands over 20 years, raising a daughter named Mary alone since her mother's death from fever a decade before. Mary Voss was 26 years old, capable and quietly stubborn in exactly the way that had kept her father's land solvent through droughts that had ruined considerably larger operations. And it was precisely that visible competence, that quiet dignity neither cruelty nor poverty had ever managed to break, that made her the specific target Garrick eventually settled on when four separate offers for the Voss bottomland had all been refused. A week before the stranger ever rode into the valley, Garrick had sent Silas Cobb and two other men to the Voss homestead under the pretense of a final negotiation.
When Henry Voss refused a fifth time, calmly and without raising his own voice, Cobb had seized Mary Voss in front of her father, forced her to her knees in the yard, and cut her hair to the scalp with a hunting knife while two other men held her father back at gunpoint, unable to do anything but watch. It was not a killing. It was, in Garrick's own careful accounting, considerably worse than a killing, precisely because it was designed to be survived, to be carried forward as a visible, permanent reminder to every family in Cedar Hollow of exactly what continued resistance would eventually cost them. That act was the proof of threat that should have told any careful observer exactly what kind of operation Wade Garrick had built in Cedar Hollow over three patient years. Not an operation built on simple murder, which drew scrutiny, but one built on humiliation calibrated precisely to break a person's spirit while leaving her alive to demonstrate the cost of defiance to everyone who saw her afterward.
The valley's own marshal, a compromised and thoroughly intimidated man named Otis Ward, had ridden out to the Voss homestead following the incident, taken a brief statement, and ruled the matter a private family dispute beyond his jurisdiction, precisely as Garrick's considerable financial reach had ensured he always would. The stranger rode into Cedar Hollow the following week on a gray overcast afternoon with nothing about him remarkable enough to draw more than a passing glance from the handful of wary homesteaders still working land along the creek. He rode a lean chestnut gelding gone thin from a long stretch of hard trail, wore a plain weather-stained canvas duster, and kept a battered brown hat pulled low enough that the general store owner who sold him supplies that morning, a cautious man named Otto Fenn, couldn't afterward have said with any real confidence what color his eyes were. He had no particular business in Cedar Hollow beyond resting his horse before continuing whatever journey he'd started weeks before and had stopped at the Voss homestead entirely by chance, drawn by nothing more than the sight of a working well at the edge of the property at the exact moment Wade Garrick had ridden out with Silas Cobb to deliver his final ultimatum before Friday's deadline. He arrived in time to see Mary Voss kneeling in the yard, her scalp still raw and healing from the week before.
Her father held at a careful distance by two more of Garrick's hired men. While Garrick himself stood over her holding a fistful of her hair he'd just cut a second time, driving the point home with the particular patient cruelty of a man who had learned that repetition made a threat considerably more durable than a single act ever could. " Your daddy's got till Friday to sign, Henry. " Garrick was saying. " Next time it won't be her hair I take. "