debated audition requirements, tuition, and whether students should submit recordings made on phones. Celia attended as the faculty representative, visibly unhappy with a process she had not designed. Meredith sometimes arrived halfway through meetings and asked whether they had developed a compelling donor narrative. Keisha would reply that they were developing a functioning program, and the donor narrative could wait until it had something true to describe.
They proposed a pilot with twelve students: six young musicians from households that could not afford conventional private lessons, three adults returning to music after caregiving or career interruptions, and three students nominated by community organizations that had never before had a formal connection to Meridian. Admission would be based on a live skills session rather than polished videos or long lists of competitions. Applicants could demonstrate musical memory, technique, listening, and potential on whatever instrument they knew. Those who needed development would not be dismissed as failures. They would be told what work might help them improve and invited to apply again.
The first budget meeting was sobering. Practice rooms cost money to maintain. Teaching time had to be paid. Transportation could be a barrier for children traveling from neighborhoods poorly served by transit after dark. An instrument-lending fund would require repairs, insurance, and storage. The donor office wanted the program to begin with a high-profile concert and photos of smiling recipients. Eleanor argued that the pilot should begin with safe transportation and a consistent schedule. "A child who cannot get home at nine o'clock doesn't need our inspirational poster," she said. "She needs a ride and somebody accountable for making sure it happens."
Keisha backed her. Aaron asked the finance officer to produce real figures rather than optimistic estimates. Celia sighed that resources were being diverted from excellence. Eleanor replied that a program with no meaningful resources would divert students from hope into disappointment, which was worse. After weeks of work the committee approved a scaled pilot with paid faculty hours, a small stipend for participants facing transportation costs, and a pool of refurbished instruments donated through community partners. It was smaller than the communications department wanted and more durable than the trustees initially imagined.
Lucia Morales became the first applicant Eleanor met in a formal audition setting. Her mother, Daniela, arrived carrying a plastic folder of school reports and apology notes explaining why a previous lesson had been missed due to shift work. Her father, Miguel, waited outside because he had driven directly from a delivery route and did not want his work boots marking the conservatory floor. Eleanor went to fetch him and said the floor had survived worse than boots. He laughed uncertainly and came inside. Lucia played a short Bach piece, a Debussy excerpt, and a melody she had taught herself from her grandmother's old recording. Her technical gaps were real. So was her imagination.