It tells a complete story with dates, and the story predates the competing application by a substantial margin. He let out a breath he hadn't fully known he was holding. " Will it be enough?"He said. "" I believe so. "
I'm going to be honest. I've done a lot of prior art research. I've gone through a lot of inventor documentation. Most of it is incomplete, undated, inconsistent. "
She looked at the shelf of numbered notebooks. " This is not that. " After she left, Ryan stood in the garage for a long time. The close call quality of it, the way something he'd done reflexively, habitually, without strategic intention, had turned out to be the thing that protected him, sat with him in a particular way.
He called Sophia that evening. " Margaret said the documentation is strong,"Sophia said when he reported the session. " She told me. She also told me not to be certain.
She's right, but I've worked with Margaret for 3 years. " When she says, "I believe so,"she means it. A pause. " How are you doing?" "
I keep thinking about the notebooks,"he said. " If I'd been less obsessive about dating them." " You weren't, though." " Right, but if Ryan,"her voice was direct, but not without something softer underneath it. "
You can run that scenario as long as you want, or you can spend the energy on the scale up geometry review I sent you yesterday. " He almost smiled. That's not a very sympathetic response. I'm not a very sympathetic person.
A beat. But for what it's worth, what you built in that garage, the way you documented it, the fact that you took it seriously enough to treat it like professional work when you had no professional context for it. That's why we're in a strong position right now. That's not luck.
He didn't say anything for a moment. Okay. He said, ""Send me the geometry review. "" She sent it.
He worked on it until midnight. The patent dispute resolved 3 months later in Vidian's favor, or rather in Ryan's favor since his name was on the filing, with Margaret Okafor establishing prior art clearly enough that the German group's application was required to narrow its claims to the specific elements that didn't overlap with Ryan's work. Ryan heard about the resolution by email. He was in the garage at the time running a thermal cycle test on the latest scale-up prototype that James had shipped to him for physical evaluation alongside the simulation work.
The email came in on his phone, one line from Margaret. Priority confirmed, filing proceeds as submitted. He set the phone down. He checked the temperature gauge.
He wrote the reading in the 12th notebook. Then in the margin next to the reading, he wrote the date, the way he always did. Spring came to Cedar Creek with the particular abruptness of northeastern Springs. Two weeks of mud and gray.