Or perhaps, Dr. Crawford interjected, emotion is exactly what classical music needs right now. We've spent decades making it so rarified, so untouchable that we've driven away entire generations of potential listeners. Meanwhile, we wonder why concert halls are dying and orchestras are going bankrupt. This is absurd, Harrington snapped.
We're not going to lower our standards just to appeal to mass audiences. Classical music is meant to be challenging, sophisticated. It's meant to be universal, Marcus said quietly. Everyone turned to look at him. He'd been standing silently near the piano, watching this debate rage around him like he was in the eye of a hurricane.
Now he stepped forward, his voice small but clear. When Beovven wrote music, he didn't write it just for rich people, Marcus continued. He wrote it for everyone. That's why his ninth symphony uses Ode to Joy, a poem about all of humanity being brothers. When Shopan wrote his revolutionary attitude, he wasn't thinking about concert halls.
He was thinking about his country being destroyed. Music is supposed to speak to people to make them feel things. The minute you make it only for certain people, you've killed what makes it special. You're 14 years old, Harrington said coldly. You have no idea what you're talking about.
Maybe not about everything, Marcus agreed. But I know how music makes me feel. I know that when I play, I'm not trying to show off or prove I'm better than anyone. I'm trying to communicate something that I can't say with words. And I think that's what the great composers wanted too.
The great composers, Harrington said with exaggerated patience, were products of their time and culture. They studied for years under masters. They had access to the finest instruments, the best education, the cultural millu that allowed their genius to flourish. You cannot separate the art from the conditions that created it. But sir, Marcus said, isn't that the point?
That even though they came from that world, their music transcended it. Bach was a church organist in a small German town, but his music speaks to people everywhere. Mozart was Austrian, but Japanese kids study his compositions. Music doesn't care where you're from or what you look like. It just is.
For a long moment, Harrington didn't respond. He stood very still, his jaw working, clearly fighting some internal battle. Finally, he spoke and his voice was like ice. You want to know the truth? Marcus Williams.
The real truth. He stepped closer to Marcus, towering over him. You played well tonight. Better than well. You have talent, genuine talent.
But talent isn't enough in this world. It never has been. This industry, this art form, operates on networks and connections and cultural capital that you simply don't have and never will have. You could practice for 10,000 hours and you still wouldn't be able to open the doors that trust fund children open with a single phone call. He gestured around the hall.
Look at this audience. Do you see a single person who looks like you? This isn't because there aren't talented black musicians. We both know there are. It's because this world has very specific requirements for entry.
Requirements that have nothing to do with how well you play. You need the right schools, the right teachers, the right connections. You need parents who can afford to send you to summer programs in Europe and buy you instruments that cost more than cars. So, you're saying I should just give up? Marcus asked that I should accept that no matter how hard I work, it won't matter because of where I come from.
I'm saying you should be realistic, Harrington said. I'm saying that you should find a path that's actually available to you, get a good education, find a stable job, maybe teach music at a local school. There's no shame in that. But thinking you can just walk onto this stage and claim a place in a world that took centuries to build, that's not determination. That's delusion.
The words hit Marcus like physical blows because part of him had always feared they might be true. Part of him had always wondered if his dreams were just that, dreams with no connection to reality. But then he remembered something Mrs. Chen had told him once. They'd been working on a particularly difficult passage from a Mozart sonata, and Marcus had been ready to give up, convinced he'd never get it right.
Marcus, she'd said, "In China, when I was young, they told girls that music was a hobby, not a career. They told me I should be practical, study something useful. But I knew that music was what I was meant to do. So, I practiced harder than anyone. I proved them wrong.
Not because I was exceptional, but because I refused to let other people's limitations become mine. " Marcus looked up at Harrington and saw something in the maestro's eyes that he hadn't noticed before. Fear. This man wasn't trying to protect the sanctity of classical music. He was trying to protect his own position in a hierarchy that Marcus' very existence threatened. Because if a poor black kid from the South Bronx could teach himself to play at this level, what did that say about all the expensive education and prestigious programs that formed the foundation of Harrington's world?
What did it say about the entire system that guaranteed certain people success while denying others even the chance to try? You're right, Marcus said quietly. I don't have the connections or the money or the right background. But I have something you don't have anymore. And what's that?
Harrington asked mockingly. I have nothing to lose. The words hung in the air between them, simple but profound. Marcus watched understanding flicker across Vincent Harrington's face and with it a flash of something that might have been respect quickly suppressed. "Nothing to lose," Harrington repeated slowly.
"How very dramatic. " "Tell me, Marcus, what do you think happens next in this fairy tale you've constructed? " "You play three pieces adequately, and suddenly the doors of Carnegie Hall swing open. Agents line up to represent you. Recording contracts materialized from thin air. I think, Marcus said, his voice steady despite his racing heart that I proved I can play. The rest is up to people like you, whether you'll let someone like me in or whether you'll keep pretending talent only exists in people who already have everything.
A cell phone camera flash went off somewhere in the audience. Then another. Marcus suddenly realized that dozens of people were recording this confrontation. This wasn't just happening in this room anymore. This was going out into the world onto social media where the gatekeepers had less control over the narrative.
Harington noticed too. His expression shifted, became more calculated. He was a performer after all, and he understood audiences. The crowd was no longer entirely on his side, and any overt cruelty now would be captured and shared and potentially damage his carefully cultivated reputation. "You want the truth," Harrington said.
And now his voice carried a note of something almost like sincerity. Here it is. The world of professional classical music is brutal. It chews up and spits out talented people every single day. People who've studied since they were three years old, who've won competitions, who've done everything right, they still fail.
They still end up teaching lessons in strip malls or playing in hotel lobbies. That's the reality. I'm not trying to be cruel. I'm trying to save you from wasting years of your life on a dream that statistically won't happen, but it could happen. Catherine Worththington said, still standing in the audience.
Vincent, you talk about statistics and reality, but every successful musician was once someone people doubted. You were once a young pianist trying to make it. Someone gave you a chance. I was properly trained, Harrington shot back. I attended Giuliard at 16.
I won the Van Klyber competition. I paid my dues through years of discipline study. Your father was Maxwell Harrington, Dr. Crawford interrupted. The Maxwell Harrington who owned three concert halls and personally knew Leonard Bernstein.
Let's not pretend you climbed the mountain alone, Vincent. The crowd murmured. This was information most people knew, but politely didn't mention. Harrington had talent certainly, but he'd also had advantages that most musicians could only dream of. Harrington's face tightened.