Made me feel like I don't know anything. Good, his mother said firmly. That means he's taking you seriously. If he thought you were hopeless, he wouldn't bother pointing out what needs fixing. He'd just smile and tell you, "You're doing great. " She pulled back to look at him.
"Your father used to say that the hardest teachers are the ones who see potential in you, the ones who don't see potential. They're always encouraging, always positive, because it doesn't matter to them whether you improve or not. But the teachers who push you until you want to quit, those are the ones who believe you can be more than you are. Marcus thought about that as he ate a late dinner and then settled at the kitchen table with his keyboard. He practiced the churnney aude until his fingers felt like they might fall off.
Then practiced some more. At midnight, his mother finally made him stop and go to bed. You've got school tomorrow. She reminded him and practice at the church. After you need sleep.
As Marcus lay in bed staring at the ceiling, he thought about what Harington had said. You don't belong. Not yet. Not yet. That meant someday maybe he could.
It wasn't much, but it was enough to hold on to. The next eight weeks were the hardest of Marcus's life. Every Monday, Wednesday, and Friday, he took the subway to Harrington's penthouse studio. Every lesson was a battle, not against Harrington, but against his own limitations, against the gaps in his training that seemed to yawn wider the more he learned. Week two.
Harington introduced him to his other students. This is Christina Vulov, Harrington said, gesturing to a girl of about 16 with ice blonde hair and the kind of poise that came from a lifetime of privilege. Christina's been playing since she was four. She won the junior division of the Montreal International Competition last year. Christina, this is Marcus Williams.
He's been playing for 3 years. Christina's eyebrows rose in obvious disdain. 3 years and he's studying with you. A temporary arrangement, Harrington said smoothly. I'm curious to see how quickly proper instruction can develop raw talent.
Marcus felt like a specimen under a microscope as Christina played her piece. A list atude so technically demanding that watching her fingers was like watching someone perform surgery. She was brilliant, flawless, and she knew it. When it was Marcus' turn, he played the boach prelude he'd been working on. He made it through without major errors, but compared to Christina's list, it sounded childishly simple.
Competent, Harrington said when he finished. Your Bach is improving. Though I should mention that Christina learned that same prelude when she was seven. The comparison hung in the air like poison. Christina smirked.
But Marcus noticed something else. Yes, Christina's playing was technically superior, but it was also cold. Perfect, but emotionless, like a computer program to play the notes, but not understand their meaning. He didn't say anything. He'd learned that lesson, but he filed the observation away.
Week four, disaster struck. Marcus arrived at Harrington's studio to find two men he didn't recognize sitting in the corner with cameras. His stomach dropped. Documentary crew, Harrington explained. They're filming a project about my teaching method.
You'll ignore them. But Marcus couldn't ignore them. Knowing he was being recorded made him self-conscious, and self-consciousness made him tense. When he played his prepared piece, Shopen's nocturn in Eflat major, his fingers felt like wooden sticks. He made mistakes he'd never made in practice, fumbled passages he could normally play in his sleep.
"Stop," Harrington said after the second page. "You're playing like a frightened rabbit. What's wrong with you? The cameras will be at every major performance you ever give. " Harrington cut him off. Do you think concert pianists only play when there are no cameras?
This is the profession, Marcus. People watching, judging, recording. If you can't handle two cameramen in a practice studio, how will you handle Carnegie Hall? I just need to You need to develop mental toughness. Harington stood and walked to the piano.
You know what separates great performers from mediocre ones? It's not talent. Talent is common. It's the ability to perform under pressure, to shut out distractions, to execute when everything in your brain is screaming at you that you're about to fail. That's what you lack.
He gestured to the cameras. These men will be here for the next month. Get used to them. And if you can't play under these conditions, maybe you're not cut out for this after all. The words stung worse than any technical criticism.
Marcus forced himself to start again. And this time, he made it through, though not well. The rest of the lesson was excruciating. On the subway home, Marcus pulled out his phone and found dozens of messages waiting. The documentary crews presence had leaked online, and people were already speculating about whether Marcus was succeeding or failing.
Bet Harington's making his life hell. Kids probably ready to quit. This is what happens when you let amateurs into professional spaces. Marcus turned off his phone and stared out the subway window at the darkness rushing past. The anonymous commenter might be right.
Maybe he was ready to quit. But then he remembered Christina's cold, perfect list. He remembered Harrington's words, "Talent is common. " He remembered his mother's face when she told him about his father's lost dreams. He wasn't going to quit. Week six brought a different kind of challenge.
Concert in two weeks, Harrington announced at the start of the lesson. Small venue, invitationonly audience, about 200 people. All four of my students will perform. You'll each play a 10-minute program of your choice. Start planning.
Marcus felt panic rising in his chest. A concert. But I'm not ready. You're never ready. Harington said, "That's not the point.
The point is to expose you to performance pressure in a controlled environment. Pick your pieces and start preparing. I'd suggest sticking to what you know well. This isn't the time for ambitious new repertoire. " But Marcus didn't want to play it safe. He'd spent 6 weeks being the weakest student, the charity case, the experiment that might or might not work.
He wanted to prove something to Harrington, to Christina and the other students, to everyone watching online. So instead of choosing safe pieces, he selected a program that was just beyond his current ability. Mozart's piano sonata number 16 in C major, the famous Sonata Facil, though it was only easy compared to Mozart's other works, WC's Clare DeLoon, and because he couldn't resist, a brief piece by Scott Joplain, Maple Leaf Rag. When he told Harrington his selections, the maestro frowned. The Joplain?
Why? Because it's part of my heritage. Marcus said quietly. Because Scott Joplain was a black composer who created something beautiful and original, and most classical music programs ignore him completely. Because if I'm going to perform, I want to perform music that means something to me.
Harington studied him for a long moment. The classical music establishment doesn't take ragtime seriously. Maybe that's the problem with the classical music establishment. For the first time in 6 weeks, Harrington smiled, not warmly exactly, but with something that might have been respect. Fair enough.
But that piece needs to be absolutely perfect. Ragtime is technically demanding, and people will be looking for any excuse to dismiss it as inferior music. Don't give them ammunition. I won't. Marcus practiced like a demon for the next two weeks.