Naomi filed the letter with the others. She was grateful for any resources that would help families, but her deepest satisfaction came from watching Isaiah grow into someone whose future did not depend on Vincent's attention. Her son had his own interests, disappointments, friends, and chances to make mistakes. He wanted to be a firefighter for a while, then a veterinarian, then an engineer who designed bridges that dogs could cross. Naomi encouraged his curiosity without turning any passing ambition into a destiny. He was allowed to change his mind.
Biscuit grew from a restless puppy into a patient golden dog with a grayish muzzle and an undiminished interest in kitchen crumbs. He still reacted strongly to unfamiliar sounds, although training had made him easier to reassure. On walks he stayed close to Isaiah, who had grown tall enough to hold the leash with one relaxed hand. The collar Vincent sent after the incident, blue leather with a small tag reading HERO, remained in a drawer because it had become too small. Isaiah kept it anyway, not as a trophy, but because it reminded him of the puppy who first made their apartment noisier and happier.
The first time Isaiah returned to Charles Street without feeling frightened, he was nearly eleven. Naomi had errands nearby and asked whether he wanted to take a different route. He said they could walk the old way. The block looked disappointingly ordinary. A bakery had replaced one shop, the curb was newly painted, and the bus still sighed at its stop. No black SUV waited there. No bodyguards stood beside a suitcase. People crossed the street without knowing anything remarkable had happened there years before.
They stopped near the grocery where Naomi had been shopping that morning. Isaiah looked through the window and remembered the milk she never bought. "You left the bread too," he said. Naomi laughed. "I did. We had eggs for dinner because I forgot everything else." Isaiah scratched Biscuit behind the ears. "He really was loud." "He was," Naomi agreed. "And you were loud enough when you needed to be."
They walked on. Isaiah did not ask to see a memorial or tell the story again. His hand tightened briefly around the leash when a truck backfired down the street, then relaxed as Biscuit turned to investigate a fallen leaf. Naomi noticed the moment and said nothing. It belonged to her son, not to an audience. The ordinary city closed around them: shoes on pavement, distant bells, a cyclist calling for room, and the smell of bread from an open bakery door.
At home that evening Isaiah worked on a school essay about a person who had changed his life. Naomi assumed he might choose Thomas, Captain Price, or even Biscuit. Instead he wrote about her. He described how she came home tired and still remembered his favorite breakfast, how she answered questions without pretending everything was simple, and how she taught him he could ask for help without being ashamed. He included a sentence about the suitcase, but only to explain what she had told him afterward: a child is not responsible for fixing an adult's danger.