"A shilling, I hear, for 93 ewes and a ram." He laughed, and the spaniel wagged. "A duke has robbed a beggar, and the beggar thanked him for it. That is a rare morning's work." Catherine did not answer. She had been schooled in silence by 6 months of grief and 4 months of a landlord's cold civility, and she had learned that a closed mouth was cheaper than any retort.
She waited until the squire tired of his own voice and stood aside, and she went on down the lane without looking back. She had almost reached the turning for the Duke's fields when she saw the old woman. She was sitting on a low bench against the sunny side of a cottage, wrapped in a dark shawl, with a distaff in her lap and a bowl of unspun wool at her feet. Her hands moved without her eyes. She had been a shepherd's wife once, so people said, though her husband had been in the ground longer than most in the village had been alive.
Catherine slowed. The old woman lifted her chin without stopping the wheel of her fingers. "Come here, girl."
Catherine came. The old woman looked at her for what felt like a long time. Then she reached into the bowl and took out a small pinch of the raw wool and held it up between her thumb and forefinger so that the light passed through it. "There is more in a beast," she said, "than what has been done to it." Catherine waited for more.
None came. The old woman lowered her hand and returned to her spinning, and after a moment, Catherine understood that she had been dismissed. She said thank you, though she was not sure for what, and walked on. The words followed her down the lane like a hand laid lightly on her shoulder, and she did not yet know what they weighed.
Beyond the last cottage, the land opened out into the Duke's grazing, and here the wind came off the moor with the wet smell of last night's rain still in it. The pens stood a half mile out at the low end of a long gray slope, and even from that distance, she could see the dark, uneven shape of the flock inside them, packed close as though the hurdles were the only thing holding them upright. A pair of rooks lifted from a fence post as she came. The sky above was the flat pale color of skimmed milk. She walked with her hands buried in the folds of her shawl, and she did not hurry because she wanted her first sight to be honest, and she wanted her legs steady when she reached it.
The pens were worse than the drovers had said. The hurdles leaned. The straw underfoot had gone to black slurry. The trough was cracked across its length, and what water stood in it had a skin of green on top. And the animals themselves, Catherine set her hand on the top rail and made herself look at each one.
Ewes with hip bones sharp as tent poles, fleeces matted into slabs that hung from their sides in filthy plates so thick with tag and burr that the shape of the animal underneath was hidden. One ewe stood on three legs. Another had a milky film across the near eye. The ram, off in a corner by himself, watched her without lifting his head. She stood a long while at the rail.
She did not weep, though her throat closed once, and she had to swallow it down. She counted them. 93, as the steward had said, and the ram besides. She marked in her mind the ones that were worst. She listened to the sound of them, which was not the peaceful murmuring of a healthy fold, but a wet, laboring breath from too many mouths at once.
The village was right. The drovers were right. The steward had told her plainly, and she had understood him plainly. And yet, under all of that, beneath the stink and the sag and the ruin, was a thing the old woman had pinched between her fingers and held to the light. Catherine did not name it to herself yet.
She only stood at the rail and let herself look. She did not go back to the cottage that night. She fetched her shawl tighter and set her back against the leeward side of the pens and sat down on the wet ground and there she stayed. The wind moved over the moor. A star or two came out between the ragged clouds.
The ewes shifted and settled and shifted again and after a long time one of them a small one near the corner came to the hurdle and pressed her head against the wood a few feet from Catherine's shoulder and stood there breathing. Catherine reached up without turning and laid two fingers against the matted wool at the ewe's neck. Under the felted crust deep down where her fingertips just reached was warmth and beneath the warmth was something else a softness faint as a rumor that had no business being there in an animal so far gone. She kept her hand where it was until the ewe drifted away. Then she drew her shawl over her head and slept as best she could with her back to the hurdles.
And all through the night in her half-sleep she listened. Dawn came gray and slow. Catherine woke to the sound of the flock stirring and to a stiffness in her shoulders that felt honestly earned as if she had begun some work already by simply staying. She stood brushed the wet straw from her skirt and walked the perimeter of the pens in the pale light. Frost had come thinly overnight.
It lay in the hoof prints and along the tops of the leaning hurdles like a whitening of chalk. She counted the flock again out of habit. 93 ewes one ram the steward had not shorted her by so much as a lamb. It was as she came around the far side of the pen, where the hurdles butted against an older set of posts sunk in the ground long before the Duke had ever run stock there, that she saw the first thing that did not fit. On the weathered face of the corner post, low down, half swallowed by lichen, someone had cut a small mark with the point of a knife.
Not the Duke's brand, not the parish mark. Two letters, an S and a lowered M, twined together in a way that looked more like a maker's sign than a shepherd's tally. Below them, so faint she had to crouch and rub the moss aside with her thumb, was a date. She could make out an eight and a three, and what might have been a four, a year older than she was. Catherine stayed crouched a long time.
She did not know what to do with the mark. It belonged to no one she knew, and no one had told her the pens had stood here before the Duke's men had thrown their hurdles up. She thought of the drover's laughing voice, fleece like felted rags, and she thought of the softness she had felt in the night beneath a ewe's matted crust, and she found she could not join the two thoughts together in the way the village had joined them.
She rose. She let the moss fall back over the letters. She did not tell herself what the mark meant because she did not yet know, and she had been taught by her uncle not to ask a thing to answer before it was ready. She only fixed the place of it in her mind. Corner post, northwest side, beneath the lichen.
Then she turned back to the flock and began the day's proper work, which was the work of not letting any more of them die before nightfall. She walked into the village and knocked at the yard of the loyal old friend her mother had once written of, a wheelwright named John Barrow, who had known her uncle in his younger years, and who greeted her at the gate with the plain, unsurprised warmth of a man who had already heard everything the parish had to say, and had set none of it against her. Catherine asked for the loan of a barrow, a fork, a stout brush, and a length of rope. John Barrow gave her all four without comment, and added a wedge of bread wrapped in linen. He said, "You will want water carried."
She said, "I will." He said, "I will bring some by cart at noon." That was the whole of their exchange. She was halfway back up the lane when a low gray shape came out from beneath the hedge and fell into step behind her. It was an old sheepdog, thin along the ribs, one ear torn to a stub, its muzzle gone almost white.
It kept a courteous six paces behind her and did not answer when she stopped and looked back. John Barrow, when she asked him later, said the dog had belonged to the Duke's last shepherd and had been left behind with the pens when the man went south. No one had thought to feed it. It had lived, he said, on what it could catch. It had a name once, but he did not remember it.